The borrowing-cost advantage the United States has long enjoyed from issuing Treasury debt has eroded and flipped into a premium, according to a new analysis from the Brookings Institution. The shift means the US now pays more to borrow in 10-year markets than a trade-weighted average of its advanced-economy peers, once currency hedging is accounted for.
Robin Brooks, a senior fellow in Economic Studies at Brookings, examined the so-called convenience yield — the benefit the US gets because global investors value the safety and liquidity of Treasuries. In the early 2010s, the US could issue 10-year debt at an average of over 10 basis points below comparable government bonds in Germany, Japan, the UK, Canada, Switzerland, Sweden and Australia. That advantage has since reversed: the US now pays a premium of around 10 basis points above that peer group, Brooks reported.
The erosion has been gradual and correlates most clearly with the rising supply of Treasury debt, which Brooks links to large US fiscal deficits that are diminishing the scarcity and specialness of Treasuries. US public debt is approaching 130% of GDP, far above Switzerland's level of just under 40% and Germany's roughly 65%.
To put the US trend in perspective, Brooks compared it with the convenience yields of Switzerland and Germany, two countries traditionally considered safe havens. The comparison, he wrote, helps build intuition about how these measures behave.
Switzerland, despite its low debt, has not generally enjoyed a borrowing-cost advantage in calm markets — it has on average paid a premium on its debt issuance. But when global volatility rises, demand for Swiss safe-haven assets increases and its convenience yield climbs. That pattern has played out in recent years as policy volatility in the US and sovereign debt stress in the eurozone have returned, pushing Switzerland's convenience yield near historical highs.
Germany's picture is more complicated. Its convenience yield has eroded in recent years, especially since early 2025 when Germany softened its debt brake to finance rearmament following Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The return of eurozone debt worries has lifted Germany's convenience yield more recently, but it remains low in historical perspective, Brooks noted.
For the US, the premium on 10-year Treasuries stabilized above 15 basis points after 2022 and has edged down to around 10 basis points since 2025. Brooks said this compression is likely because rising global interest rates since COVID-19 have highlighted the precarious state of public finances worldwide, with high-debt European countries looking especially vulnerable. That helps the US look better on a relative basis, even though its absolute borrowing costs are rising.
Brooks acknowledged that the recent narrowing of the US premium is counterintuitive, given erratic US foreign and domestic policy. One might expect the risk premium on Treasury debt to keep growing, he wrote, but global uncertainty seems to have benefited the US to some degree, helping compress the premium it had been paying.
The analysis draws on research by Jiang et al. (2025) and Du et al. (2026), which have documented the sharp erosion in the US convenience yield in recent years. Du et al. found that the convenience yield for the US dollar itself remains robust, underscoring that the US status as an investment destination and safe haven remains intact.
Brooks cautioned that convenience yields are volatile because they capture financial market sentiment embedded in asset prices, which can change from one day to the next. The level at any single point is less informative than the evolution over time, he wrote.
The big takeaway, Brooks concluded, leans in the direction that sound fiscal policy gets rewarded. That is why Switzerland and Germany have convenience yields and the US pays a premium. It is also consistent with the erosion of Germany's convenience yield as its debt brake has been softened.
For university students, the analysis carries implications for the cost of borrowing and the broader economic environment they will enter after graduation. A sustained US borrowing premium could mean higher interest rates on student loans, mortgages and other debt, as well as potential knock-on effects on job markets and public spending. Students studying finance, economics or public policy may find the comparison of fiscal trajectories across countries directly relevant to their coursework and career planning.