The U.S. government has long benefited from a unique advantage in global debt markets: it can borrow at lower interest rates than almost anyone else, because its bonds are considered the world's safest asset. But that advantage, known as the "convenience yield" on U.S. Treasuries, has been shrinking for nearly two decades, according to a recent analysis from the Brookings Institution.

The convenience yield is the difference between the yield on a U.S. Treasury security and the yield on another asset with similar risk, maturity, and payment characteristics — such as a AAA-rated corporate bond or the sovereign debt of another advanced economy. When the convenience yield is positive, the U.S. government pays less to borrow than others. Historically, it was large and positive because Treasuries were seen as the ultimate safe asset: a deep, liquid market widely accepted as high-quality collateral.

Brookings reports that the convenience yield has been declining since the Great Recession of 2007-2008 and turned negative for longer-maturity Treasury securities in the early 2010s. It fell further following the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. In other words, Treasury yields are now closer to the yields on risk-adjusted AAA corporate bonds and currency-adjusted G10 sovereign bonds than they were before the financial crisis.

According to research by Harvard's Wenxin Du, Federal Reserve Board's Ritt Keerati, and Columbia's Jesse Schreger, the convenience yield on 5-year US Treasuries relative to G10 sovereign bonds of identical maturity fell by 17 basis points, moving from a mean of -11 basis points during 2012-2020 to a mean of -28 basis points over 2021-2025.

Why this matters for students

For university students, the erosion of the Treasury convenience yield has a direct, if indirect, impact on their finances. The U.S. government is the world's largest borrower, and even small increases in interest rates add up to enormous sums. According to Brookings, 15% of all federal spending already goes to interest payments. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that if interest rates over the next decade are half a percentage point higher than it currently projects, the deficit would be $1.9 trillion larger over 10 years.

A larger deficit, in turn, could lead to reduced federal spending on programs that affect students — including research grants, student financial aid, and university funding — or to higher taxes down the line. It could also mean higher borrowing costs for student loans, which are tied to Treasury rates.

Why is the convenience yield declining?

Brookings outlines several explanations for the trend, none of which are mutually exclusive.

One theory points to the sheer volume of U.S. Treasury debt issuance. After the U.S. borrowed heavily to support the economy during the Great Recession and the COVID-19 pandemic, some researchers say the increased supply may have pushed the convenience yield down. Bondholders may be growing less confident in the U.S. government's ability or willingness to repay its debts.

"Investors increasingly see U.S. Treasury debt as risky rather than safe," Hanno Lustig of Stanford told Brookings, citing worries that the government will not be able to collect enough revenue to repay what it has borrowed. He argues that central bankers and financial regulators have not fully grasped this new reality.

Another explanation involves market structure. Paul Cochran and co-authors at the Federal Reserve Board note that regulatory and other risk management constraints could limit dealers' willingness to intermediate in Treasury markets. As Treasury supply grows relative to intermediaries' capacity, Du and co-authors Benjamin Hébert of Stanford and Wenhao Li of USC argue, the convenience yield declines.

A third factor is the changing relationship between stocks and bonds. Treasuries have traditionally served as a hedge for stock market investors: when stocks fall, Treasuries rise. But after 2021, Viral Acharya and Toomas Laarits of NYU note, stock and bond markets have moved in the same direction, weakening demand for Treasuries as a hedge and pushing down the convenience yield.

Not a sign of dollar decline

Despite the shrinking convenience yield, Brookings emphasizes that this is not a sign that the U.S. dollar is falling out of favor with global investors. Demand from international investors for other dollar-denominated assets, such as equities and corporate bonds, has remained strong, largely because of the dollar's dominant role in global payments and financing. Even after the "Liberation Day" tariff announcements in April 2025, which were associated with a depreciation of the dollar and a decline in Treasury convenience yields, the convenience yield on the dollar itself remained positive.

What to watch

The Brookings analysis does not predict where the convenience yield will go next, but it makes clear that the stakes are high. If the trend continues, the U.S. government's borrowing costs will rise, with ripple effects for the federal budget, interest rates, and ultimately for students and graduates who rely on federal programs and affordable credit.