Imagine standing in a grocery aisle comparing two protein shakes. One costs $3, the other $7. Without any further information, your brain may quickly decide the pricier option is healthier, better-tasting, or made with superior ingredients. But nobody actually told you any of that — you guessed.
According to new research from Vanderbilt Business and the University of Cincinnati, that kind of mental shortcut is far more than a simple guess. Across two recently published academic chapters, researchers Donald (Ryan) Gaffney, Frank R. Kardes, and Steven Posavac examine what happens when information is missing and why people so readily fill in the blanks — only to later treat those fill-ins as established facts.
The first chapter, "Epistemic Inference Theory: Subjective Uncertainty and the Conditions for Inference Formation," published in Advancing Consumer Psychology, introduces a framework called Epistemic Inference Theory (EIT). It distinguishes between two types of uncertainty: epistemic uncertainty, which people treat as solvable (an answer exists, we just don't have it yet), and aleatory uncertainty, which people attribute to randomness (like a dice roll). The researchers found that even subtle language shifts can change how people perceive uncertainty. Saying "I'm 80 percent sure" leads people to think about what can be known, while "there is an 80 percent chance" shifts attention toward randomness, according to the study.
When people perceive uncertainty as knowable, they actively search for clues. And when clues are scarce, the brain has a useful but potentially misleading trick: it fills in the gaps with inferences. The second chapter, "Consumer Inference and the Illusion of Knowledge," published in the Handbook of Social Psychology and Consumer Behavior, explores what happens after those gaps are filled. Consumers rarely have complete information — an ad omits details, a product page leaves questions unanswered, a review reflects only one person's experience. So people improvise, using price, brand reputation, and past experience to supply missing pieces.
The problem, the researchers explain, is that people can lose track of which parts of their judgment came from actual information and which parts they supplied themselves. They describe this as an "illusion of knowledge": an inference fills the empty space, and people begin to feel like they know more than they actually do. Time doesn't necessarily help. According to the study discussed in the chapter, shoppers who delayed a week after getting product details felt surer about their final picks and were less prone to postponing a choice — yet they recalled less of the initial information they had been given. Their actual knowledge was lower, but felt like they knew more.
For university students, this phenomenon has direct implications. Whether choosing a study program based on a university's reputation, evaluating a job offer based on salary alone, or deciding which textbook to buy based on price, students routinely make decisions with incomplete information. The instinct to fill in gaps is natural, but the research suggests that being aware of what you don't know can help keep a reasonable guess from turning into an unquestioned fact.
For businesses, the findings suggest that what companies don't tell customers can matter almost as much as what they do. Every ad, product page, review, and recommendation leaves something unanswered, and customers rarely leave those spaces empty. But consumers aren't powerless against their own assumptions. The researchers point to a simple strategy: before making a decision, take stock of which details you actually have and which ones you've filled in yourself.
So back to that $7 protein shake. Maybe it's healthier. Maybe the ingredients are better. Maybe it tastes incredible. Or maybe it just costs $7. The research suggests asking yourself: What do I actually know, and what am I just assuming?