A new study from the University of Auckland suggests that for many consumers, the meaning of "organic" food goes well beyond the certification label on a package. According to research led by Dr Xiaoxi Zhu of the university's Business School, people's understanding of organic food is shaped by trust, personal values, and everyday practices such as growing their own vegetables or buying directly from growers.
The research, published by the University of Auckland and first carried by The Conversation, draws on the experiences of 33 Chinese consumers of organic food in New Zealand and China. While the sample is not representative of all shoppers, the study offers a detailed look at how people interpret the term "organic" and incorporate it into their daily lives, the university reported.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, when in-person observation was difficult, Zhu asked participants to record short videos showing their food and how they obtained it. Some filmed their supermarket shopping, others unpacked delivery boxes, and a few took the camera into their gardens. These videos were then used to guide interviews, helping explain why particular products and activities felt important to the participants.
One participant, who had returned to China after studying in the United States, showed herself making tofu, growing bean sprouts, and harvesting vegetables on her balcony. Another unpacked a box of produce and explained how he had asked the supplier to pack it tightly and use less plastic to reduce waste. Both examples, Zhu noted, revealed how an interest in organic food influenced everyday habits in ways that a simple shopping survey might not have uncovered.
The videos also challenged some assumptions. One participant described himself as an enthusiastic organic consumer but showed expensive supermarket products without organic labels. Further discussion revealed that he associated organic food with premium prices, luxury packaging, and upmarket shops rather than with certification or production methods. His understanding differed markedly from the researchers' definition of organic food, the study found.
Trust emerged as a central theme across the research. According to a 2020 government-led consumer survey cited in the study, 21% of New Zealand respondents who did not buy organic products cited a lack of trust in organic claims as a barrier. In Zhu's study, certification was trusted by some participants, but others trusted personal recommendations, community networks, or direct ties with growers more. Skepticism toward conventional food systems occasionally spread to organic labels, leading individuals to alter where they got their food or to cultivate and cook more on their own.
The organic sector in New Zealand is substantial. Organics Aotearoa New Zealand's 2025 market report, cited in the study, valued the national organic sector at NZ$1.18 billion in 2024. While price was a barrier for many who did not buy organic, around three-quarters of respondents in the 2020 survey still reported buying organic food or drink, according to the university.
For students studying business, marketing, or food systems, the research offers a practical lesson: consumer behaviour is not always driven by official definitions or labels. Trust, personal relationships, and lifestyle practices can matter just as much as certification. The findings also highlight the value of qualitative research methods, such as video diaries and interviews, in understanding what people actually do, not just what they say they do.
Zhu's research reinforces the need for producers and retailers to provide clear information about where organic food comes from, how it is produced, and how its claims are verified. For researchers, it demonstrates the value of videos and interviews in exploring consumers' habits and attitudes beyond their purchasing decisions.
"Ultimately, what people do with food, what they value and whom they trust can tell us just as much about their choices as what they put in their shopping trolley," Zhu wrote in the article, which reflects the opinion of the author and not necessarily the views of the University of Auckland.