Australia's main climate policy for heavy industry is failing to cut emissions because it relies too heavily on cheap, low-integrity carbon offsets, according to a new report from the Australian National University (ANU).

The report, titled Phantom Forests and the Safeguard Mechanism: How Low-integrity Offsets are Obstructing Climate Action, was produced by researchers from ANU, Oxford University, UNSW, Rotterdam School of Management, Erasmus University, Haizea Analytics and the Centre for Environment and Integrity, with financial support from the Australian Conservation Foundation (ACF).

The Safeguard Mechanism (SGM) is an emissions trading scheme that applies to facilities emitting more than 100,000 tonnes of CO₂-equivalent each year. Together, these facilities account for about 29 per cent of Australia's national emissions. The scheme is designed to put a price on carbon and incentivise reductions.

But according to the report, the Australian Government's administration of the Australian Carbon Credit Unit (ACCU) scheme has created a large supply of cheap, low-integrity credits. "This is artificially suppressing the carbon price faced by SGM facilities, including large gas and coal entities, which account for 55% of emissions covered by the scheme," said Professor Andrew Macintosh, Co-Director of the ANU Centre for Environmental Markets.

The suppressed carbon price means heavy polluters have little incentive to invest in genuine emissions reductions, the report argues. Instead, they can buy inexpensive offsets rather than changing their operations. "The result is higher emissions and negligible transformation in the industrial and mining sectors," Macintosh said.

A central finding of the report concerns human-induced regeneration (HIR) projects, the largest project type in the ACCU market and, according to the researchers, the world's largest pure carbon removal project by credit issuances. Last year, HIR projects accounted for 40 per cent of all units issued in the ACCU market, and the report projects they will soon reach 50 per cent of annual issuances.

HIR projects cover 38 million hectares and claim to be regenerating native forests across at least 7.4 million hectares — an area larger than the island of Tasmania. On the current trajectory, the claimed area of regeneration could exceed 15 million hectares, more than two-thirds the size of Victoria.

However, the report's analysis, which used datasets derived from 10-metre resolution Sentinel-2 satellite imagery and very high-resolution (30–50 cm) imagery, found that most of these projects have failed. "We analysed the 50 most highly credited HIR projects on a per hectare basis and found there has been no, negligible or negative change in tree cover across the majority of the credited areas," said Professor Don Butler, also Co-Director of the ANU Centre for Environmental Markets.

Butler said the Australian Government and the Clean Energy Regulator have repeatedly denied integrity issues with HIR projects, releasing reports that claimed the projects were performing as expected. "Our analysis proves this is wrong — the majority of the projects have not resulted in significant additional regeneration and are not regenerating new forests," he said.

HIR projects have received over 60 million ACCUs, worth between A$1.5 billion and A$2 billion, according to the report.

For university students studying environmental policy, economics or climate science, the report offers a case study in how offset markets can fail when integrity is not maintained. It also raises questions about the effectiveness of market-based climate mechanisms more broadly, and about the role of independent verification in ensuring that carbon credits represent genuine emissions reductions.

The report and its appendices have been published on the ACF website.