As Thanksgiving approaches, many Americans reach for the same familiar dishes year after year. Polls cited by UVA Today indicate about three-quarters of Americans prefer traditional Thanksgiving foods, and a report from The Campbell's Company found that only 19 percent wanted to alter the green bean casserole recipe. Against that backdrop of culinary conservatism, the University of Virginia's news outlet asked several members of the UVA community to share the recipes that are simply nonnegotiable at their holiday tables.
Kenyon Bonner, UVA's vice president and chief student affairs officer, said his grandmother's creamed corn is the dish he most looks forward to. Bonner's mother's family comes from Ellenwood, Georgia, a rural town near Atlanta with a long tradition of Southern cooking. In his family, recipes were often passed down by demonstration rather than written instruction. Bonner learned the dish by watching his mother cook, just as she learned from her mother. His version uses fresh Silver Queen sweet corn, a blend of spices, and a roux of butter and flour to create a sweet, creamy and zesty flavor. Bonner noted that his mother would never use frozen corn.
UVA President Scott Beardsley shared a stuffing recipe from his wife, Claire, who is from France and did not grow up celebrating Thanksgiving. Claire's stuffing combines French garlic sausage, chopped chestnuts, diced onion and celery, rustic bread soaked in warm milk, and two tablespoons of cognac. The mixture is baked at 350°F for 45 to 55 minutes. "It would not feel like Thanksgiving without it," Beardsley said.
Ryan Odom, UVA's men's basketball coach, offered his mother's pineapple casserole, a dish he described as so sugary "you should never eat it" but one he loves. The casserole is made from canned pineapple chunks, sugar, flour, sharp cheddar cheese, and a topping of crushed Ritz Crackers mixed with melted butter. Odom's son Owen, a second-year student and walk-on player for the Cavaliers, called it "the best thing by far" and acknowledged that the cheese topping "sounds gross" but is delicious. The dish bakes at 300°F for 30 minutes.
Susan Gravatt, a 2014 UVA alumna who appeared with her husband on the Hallmark baking competition "Baked with Love, Holiday" last December, contributed a cranberry sour cream Bundt cake. Gravatt said the cake's shape and seasonal flavors remind her of holiday meals with her grandmother, who lived down the street and often brought pound cakes to family gatherings. The recipe includes fresh cranberries, sour cream, orange zest and juice, and an orange glaze made with sour cream and powdered sugar. It bakes at 350°F for 55 to 65 minutes.
According to UVA Today, these four recipes represent the kind of cherished family dishes that many Americans guard against change, offering a taste of tradition for those willing to try something new this Thanksgiving.