Standard nutritional guidance — eat more vegetables, get enough protein, limit sugar — sounds simple. But human biology is not simple, and researchers at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill's Nutrition Research Institute (NRI) are working to understand why the same meal can affect two people in completely different ways.

According to UNC-Chapel Hill, NRI scientists are tackling five core questions about how individual differences in genetics, gut microbes, and life stage shape the body's response to food. The goal is not to discard existing dietary knowledge, the university reported, but to make it more useful for the person at the dinner table.

Why the same food hits people differently

One of the institute's central puzzles is why two people can eat an identical meal and have opposite reactions — one feels fine, the other feels sleepy, bloated, or unsatisfied. "Two people can eat the same food, and one might get healthier while the other develops diabetes," NRI research specialist Walter Friday told UNC. "Why? Because nutrition depends on your genes, your environment, your lifestyle and your biology."

NRI researchers are searching for biological clues that could eventually help predict these individual responses, rather than leaving people to discover them through trial and error.

How much of a nutrient do you actually need?

Even when two people consume the same amount of a nutrient, they may not achieve the same nutritional status. Isis Trujillo-Gonzalez, an NRI assistant professor of nutrition, is studying choline — an essential nutrient involved in several critical bodily pathways. She is looking for measurable biological markers that could help researchers determine how much choline a person has actually consumed, since requirements change across the lifespan and differ between individuals.

Other NRI researchers approach the question through genetics. Natalia Krupenko, associate professor of nutrition, studies how genetic differences alter the way the body processes folate. "Science shows us that 'more of a good thing' is not always better," Krupenko told UNC. "When we recommend the same vitamin intake for everyone, we may overlook people whose enzymes process nutrients differently."

What happens inside your gut after you eat

The trillions of bacteria and other microbes living in the human gut interact with food in ways scientists are still working to understand. No two microbiomes are exactly alike. NRI faculty member Katie Meyer studies connections among diet, health behaviors, and the gut microbiome. Her research explores whether gut microbes might help explain some of the health benefits associated with healthy eating and physical activity. "These health behaviors have been associated with gut microbial features," Meyer said, "and it is possible that protective effects of diet may, in part, operate through the gut microbiota."

Does the same food matter differently at various life stages?

A nutrient that plays a critical role during fetal brain development may serve a different purpose decades later. A dietary intervention that works well for a younger adult may produce a different response in an older one. NRI scientists are studying these questions across several research programs, including differences between individuals, across the life course, and in relation to physical activity. The question, UNC reported, is not simply what people need, but when nutrition matters most and whether the right intervention at the right stage of life can change someone's long-term health trajectory.

Making nutrition information work in real life

A perfectly designed eating plan does little good if it costs too much or requires too much time. NRI faculty member Rachel Goode studies eating behavior and develops interventions designed to work within people's daily lives. "Emotional eating is rarely about willpower," Goode explained. "Precision nutrition helps us understand not only what people eat, but why."

Other NRI researchers explore how technology can provide support at precisely the right time. "Information is key, but it's not sufficient," said NRI director Deborah Tate. "Structured programs with personalized recommendations and just-in-time support outperform information alone."

For university students, the research has practical implications: the dietary advice that works for a roommate or a family member may not work for you, and future nutrition guidance could eventually be tailored to an individual's genetics, gut bacteria, and life stage rather than offering one-size-fits-all recommendations.