A new analysis from the University of Birmingham suggests that the United Kingdom's rising number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) cannot be solved by national policies alone, and that direct government intervention in local job markets may be required.
Professor Donald Houston, a professor of regional economic development at the university, released the analysis in response to the Milburn Review, a government-commissioned report on the NEET crisis. The Milburn Review, led by former Labour MP Alan Milburn, asks employers to create more first jobs, youth apprenticeships and work experience opportunities, and asks the government to make it easier, cheaper and less risky for employers to hire young people.
But Houston argues that approach overlooks a critical factor: geography.
According to the University of Birmingham's dataset, which covers 179 UK regions, local unemployment is a much stronger predictor of youth NEET rates than poor qualifications or health. NEET rates vary dramatically across the country, from just a few percent in affluent areas to over 25% in economically weaker areas.
"We therefore argue that the UK's rising NEET rate is not just a youth skills or health issue, but a geographical and economic one," Houston said in a statement published by the university.
Houston's analysis suggests that in regions where the local labour market is already weak, asking employers to create more jobs for young people may not be realistic. Hard-pressed employers in the areas with the most NEETs will struggle to create more jobs, he said.
"Governments seem to have largely given up on the idea of putting direct measures in place to ensure that young people can become established in the labour market during economically challenging times," Houston said. "National, supply-side policies and employer incentives cannot solve this on their own."
He called for a "mindset shift" on the responsibility of government towards young people, arguing that where local labour markets are weakest, the government must take greater responsibility for creating routes into work, including direct job creation.
"If we're to avoid writing off a generation and our collective economic future," Houston said, direct government action is needed.
The analysis comes as the UK continues to grapple with a rising NEET rate, a trend that has been exacerbated by the economic fallout of the pandemic and subsequent cost-of-living crisis. For university students and recent graduates, the findings underscore the importance of local economic conditions in shaping job prospects. Students studying in or planning to move to regions with weaker labour markets may face a more difficult transition into employment, regardless of their qualifications or health.
The University of Birmingham's research adds a geographical dimension to a debate that has often focused on individual-level factors such as skills, motivation or health. By highlighting the role of local job availability, Houston's analysis suggests that policy solutions must be tailored to the specific economic conditions of different regions, rather than relying on a one-size-fits-all national approach.
Houston's full analysis was published by the University of Birmingham on 18 November 2026.