A new study from the University of Georgia suggests that many young adults think they know more about personal finance than they actually do, a finding that could help educators design more effective financial literacy programs.

Published in the Journal of Consumer Affairs, the study analyzed data from the 2021 National Financial Capability Study, which surveyed more than 7,000 adults aged 18 to 34. Researchers asked participants about interest rates, inflation, mortgages and investing, and compared their self-assessed knowledge with their actual performance on a short quiz.

Using a statistical method that accounted for participants' confidence, correct answers and willingness to say "I don't know," the researchers identified four groups: consistently high knowledge, overconfident, reluctant to answer, and consistently low knowledge. According to the study, about one in four participants fell into the overconfident group.

Travis Mountain, co-author of the study and a UGA Cooperative Extension financial planning specialist in the College of Family and Consumer Sciences, told UGA's Field Report that the overconfident group's self-assessed confidence was nearly as high as that of the group with genuinely strong financial knowledge. In fact, the overconfident group rated itself slightly higher.

But the gap in actual knowledge was stark. Participants with consistently high knowledge answered an average of 5.1 out of seven questions correctly, while those classified as overconfident averaged just 2.5 correct answers.

"Feeling knowledgeable doesn't necessarily translate into making well-informed financial decisions," Mountain said.

Mountain noted that the study also distinguished between participants who gave wrong answers and those who said they didn't know. "Someone who gives an incorrect answer may be different from someone who recognizes that they don't know the answer, and we wanted to preserve that distinction," he explained.

The findings suggest that financial education could be more effective if it helps people recognize the limits of their own knowledge, rather than just trying to build knowledge from scratch. Mountain said that people with similar financial knowledge scores may need different kinds of support. Someone who knows they don't understand a concept may approach learning differently than someone who believes they have it mastered.

"Financial education should help people understand both the material and the limits of their knowledge," Mountain said. "We want people to feel comfortable making financial decisions, but we also want that confidence to be supported by true understanding."

For students and young adults, the study offers a practical takeaway: before making a financial decision — comparing loan offers, evaluating an investment, or making a major purchase — it is worth checking what you actually understand and asking questions about what you don't. Mountain said being comfortable saying "I don't know" and asking questions is a valuable financial skill in its own right.

The study was published in the Journal of Consumer Affairs and reported by UGA's Field Report.