Democrats won a decisive midterm victory in November, fueled in part by promises to end the war in Iran and scale back the use of tariffs. With those pledges now raising expectations that a Democratic-controlled Congress will soon push for major shifts in U.S. foreign policy, the question of how much influence lawmakers can actually exert has taken on new urgency, according to an analysis published by the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR).

Much of U.S. diplomacy lies beyond direct congressional control, CFR expert James M. Lindsay wrote in a November 18 article. Only the president decides whether to negotiate, with whom, and over what. Congress can hope that President Donald Trump takes a tougher line with Russian President Vladimir Putin or adopts a more conciliatory tone with U.S. allies, but it cannot impose those views on the White House.

Even in areas where Congress has clear constitutional authority, such as tariff policy or appropriations, its powers can be difficult to wield. Congress sets policy by passing laws, which requires building consensus on how bills are written and then navigating obstacles that often derail them. Democrats emphasized what they were against during the campaign but not necessarily what they were for, Lindsay noted. Senate Democrats intend to preserve the filibuster, despite lacking the necessary votes to overcome one. Moreover, any legislation that passes both chambers could be subject to a presidential veto. In the last four decades, Congress has only managed to overturn two vetoes related to foreign policy..

To explore how these dynamics might play out, Lindsay spoke with former Republican Representative Will Hurd, a former CIA clandestine officer who represented Texas's twenty-third congressional district from 2015 to 2021. Hurd is currently president of Icon Prime, a defense and space-technology company, and a member of CFR's Board of Directors. The conversation was featured on the CFR podcast The President's Inbox.

Most Republicans will stand with Trump on foreign policy

The midterms did not erase the country's deep partisan divisions or make Republicans more inclined to cooperate with Democrats, Hurd said. The Republicans who survived the "blue tsunami" won in overwhelmingly red districts. Those lawmakers know two things: they have safe seats that are won in primaries, not general elections, and the president's base remains firmly behind him. Crossing the president could trigger a primary challenge in 2028. Republican lawmakers also know that the more success Democrats enjoy, the harder it will be for Republicans to take back Congress in two years.

Additionally, many of the Republicans with the deepest foreign policy expertise and the strongest inclination to curb Trump's disruptive approach are departing Congress at the end of the year, due to either retirement or defeat, Hurd noted.

Democratic unity could be hard to find

Hurd, who represented a highly competitive district stretching from San Antonio to the Texas-Mexico border and won one election by less than a thousand votes, said that positions popular within a party may not align with a constituency's views, let alone a lawmaker's own. Some Democrats won in really red districts, he noted. If a lawmaker from such a district follows the party line on policies unpopular back home, "you may not see yourself in that seat" after the next election. How well Democratic congressional leaders manage divisions within their ranks, and the policy choices they endorse, will in turn affect how Republican lawmakers respond. It is easier to find common ground when differences are narrow rather than broad, Hurd said.

Congress has changed in ways that make compromise harder

Hurd observed that the committee system in Congress was once far stronger than it is today. Committee chairs in the late 1990s had greater power and authority to pass legislation than the speaker did, he argued, and those chairs often gave more credence to members from the opposing party on their committees than to members of their own party who were not on the committee. Now, power is centralized in a congressional leadership that seeks to maximize partisan advantage.

In addition, the push for transparency in congressional decision-making, coupled with the rise of social media, has made it harder to strike deals. Hurd served on the House Intelligence Committee, which he noted has historically been less partisan than other committees, partly because most of its hearings are not televised on C-SPAN. Lawmakers today are eager to play to the galleries, a practice that was once frowned upon. "When your interest is clicks or views, versus getting your legislation across the line, then it makes it harder for legislation to happen," Hurd said.

Lindsay and Hurd also discussed how the 2028 presidential campaign will cast a long shadow over the next Congress, and why Congress should reexamine U.S. basing options in the Middle East in the wake of Operation Epic Fury.

For university students following U.S. politics, the analysis underscores that even a Democratic majority in Congress may not produce the foreign policy changes many voters anticipated. The structural and partisan barriers to legislative action remain high, meaning that Trump's foreign policy direction is likely to persist, with potential implications for international relations, trade, and military engagements that affect students studying abroad or considering careers in diplomacy and international affairs.