According to a study published in the Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders by researchers at Vanderbilt University's Peabody College, siblings who care for autistic adults with distressing behaviors—including aggression, destructiveness, and self-injury—experience a complex mix of positive and negative mental health impacts. The findings, reported by Vanderbilt News, draw on interviews with a sample group of siblings and are among the first to focus specifically on this population.
The research was prompted by a webinar hosted by disability organizations including The Arc of the United States, the Sibling Support Project, and the Vanderbilt Kennedy Center. High attendance at that event revealed a largely overlooked group: adults who are—or may become—primary caretakers for autistic siblings with challenging behaviors. Meghan Burke, professor of special education at Peabody and lead author of the study, launched the project with support from the Organization for Autism Research, and representatives from the webinar's organizers continue to inform the work.
Burke and her team, which includes autistic researchers and family members of autistic individuals, sought to understand how caring for an autistic sibling with distressing behavior affects caregivers' life choices and mental health. Little research exists on these specific sibling relationships, the university noted.
The study identified both harmful and beneficial outcomes, some of which were anticipated from existing generalized research. However, the implications for major life decisions—such as dating, marriage, and having children—were unexpected.
Drawing on Trauma Exposure Theory, which holds that repeated traumatic experiences can affect well-being, the researchers found that siblings reported trauma-like responses including worse mental health (anxiety and depression), hypervigilance about the safety of themselves and their family members, and unexpected life choices such as deciding not to marry or have children.
"In this study, they're pretty intentionally saying, 'I'm not interested in dating. I'm not interested in getting married. I'm not interested in having kids,'" Burke told Vanderbilt News. "That was a surprise." Earlier work by Burke has shown that caretakers of siblings who do not have distressing behaviors might delay such life events but not outright reject them.
Because many participants are in their 20s, 30s, and 40s, Burke noted they may not yet have assumed full caregiving roles. "So, this could be a great time to provide targeted support," she said, by helping siblings set boundaries and protect their mental health before they become primary caregivers. This support is especially important since most siblings indicated they want to continue as caretakers despite the challenges.
At the same time, the Hidden Talents Framework—which suggests that hard experiences can build strengths—helped explain positive outcomes. Siblings reported increased resilience (such as remaining calm in stressful situations), closer family relationships due to shared support systems, and careers that give back, often in special education and advocacy.
"Overall, they did seem more responsible, more empathetic, more understanding and compassionate, which I think are all benefits," Burke added.
The study is ongoing, with Burke and her team currently exploring family dynamics to include parents, siblings, and autistic adults. Burke stressed the importance of eliciting the viewpoint of each family member, especially the autistic adult. The next step, she hopes, will be examining what interventions could look like for sibling caretakers, since supporting siblings ultimately leads to better support for their family members with autism.
"We know from parents of people who take care of their loved ones with disabilities that burnout is real," Burke said. "When the parent is burned out and they're no longer able to provide caregiving, that has a downstream effect on the person with a disability." With that knowledge, she said, the team is "trying to think through what targeted supports we can develop that help sibling caretakers move into these roles if they want to, while also protecting their own mental health."
For university students who may be sibling caretakers themselves or know someone who is, the research highlights the importance of recognizing the mental health toll and the need for early, targeted support before caregiving responsibilities become overwhelming. The findings also underscore that such experiences can foster valuable strengths like resilience and empathy, which are assets in both personal and professional life.
Burke said she hopes the findings help siblings feel seen. "I hope for siblings, if they feel disenfranchised from other sibling research that they see they do have a voice. It's a voice that we care about. And it's a voice that we're now paying attention to and trying to think through the best way to support them."