A team of Cornell University engineers has uncovered the physics behind how tiny semiconductor crystals called quantum dots spontaneously arrange themselves into eye-catching patterns as a liquid evaporates — and they have learned to control the process, according to a study published Nov. 14 in Nature Communications.
Led by Tobias Hanrath, the Croll Professor in Engineering at Cornell's Duffield College of Engineering, the researchers explored how clusters of just 20 or so quantum dots — each a nanoparticle of roughly 1,000 atoms — can form structures that visually resemble tiger stripes or zebra patterns. The work marks a shift in how scientists think about imperfections in nanoscale assembly.
“One of the beautiful aspects of this paper is that you can have a film that has a lot of disorder and complexity and weird structures that haven’t been seen elsewhere, and most people would look at it and say, ‘Oh, there’s something weird going on there. Let’s make sure we avoid making the film like that,’” Hanrath said in a statement from the university. “I think the interesting conceptual shift is if you embrace the complexity and approach it as ‘Ah, I wonder what’s actually happening there? What gives rise to that?’”
Quantum dots, which won the 2023 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, are inorganic semiconductor nanoparticles whose optical and electronic properties change depending on their size and shape. That tunability makes them attractive building blocks for so-called superlattices — layered structures that could be used in next-generation displays, solar cells, sensors and other devices.
Most research has focused on making perfect, defect-free superlattices as large as possible. The Cornell team took the opposite approach, according to lead author Jonathan Palumbo, a doctoral student in the Hanrath Energy Lab.
“When people want to take the quantum dot and make a superlattice, they want to make a perfect crystal that’s as big as possible, with no grain boundaries,” Palumbo said. “But instead, what this paper explores is if we grow our super crystal as small as we can, with a cluster of maybe 20 dots, what kind of patterns can that make? And how do we step between those perfect monolayers and then stranger, smaller systems?”
To find out, Palumbo and co-author Anjali Asthagiri, a Cornell undergraduate in the Class of 2028, used a tiny syringe to deposit droplets of ethylene glycol containing quantum dots under a laser confocal microscope. Each droplet was about one-hundredth the size of a raindrop — roughly 10 nanoliters. As the droplets evaporated and shrank, they left behind what Palumbo described as “a snail tail of film, which we call the cascade of morphologies.”
Asthagiri, supported by an Engineering Undergraduate Research Grant, developed a computational model to simulate how the quantum dots ordered and packed. The simulations primarily produced tile and ribbon patterns, and the sequence of structures in the model matched what the team observed in experiments.
“During the experiments, Jonathan and I would discuss why we may be seeing these cascades and the different underlying physics phenomena at play: solvent evaporation, convection, diffusion,” Asthagiri said. “That process enabled us to start building our intuition for how to come up with a computational model.”
The researchers then showed they could control the patterns by adjusting two factors: the concentration of quantum dots in the liquid and how quickly the solvent evaporated. Slow evaporation gave the dots time to organize through a cascade of structures — from multilayers to monolayers, then to holes, ribbons and tiles. Fast evaporation, by contrast, froze the dots into a more uniform, average arrangement before distinct patterns could form.
“If the solvent evaporates very, very slowly, you end up seeing a lot of different patterns form as you drive dots initially to the edge, forming a multilayer, and then going through the cascade of multilayer to monolayer to holes, to ribbons and tiles,” Palumbo said. “If you use a really fast evaporator, instead of the film having time to organize and order from highest to lowest concentration, you just quench into some average regime.”
The physics behind the quantum-dot patterns is different from the biological processes that create stripes on tigers or zebras, but the visual resemblance is striking. Palumbo noted that once you start looking, similar patterns appear everywhere — from melting snow in Ithaca, New York, to storm formations on Saturn.
The research was supported by the National Science Foundation, the Cornell Presidential Life Science Fellowship and the Duffield Engineering Learning Initiatives Fellowship. The team used the Cornell Center for Materials Research, which is funded by the NSF Materials Research Science and Engineering Centers program.
For university students studying materials science, physics, chemistry or engineering, the work offers a glimpse into how controlling nanoscale assembly could lead to practical devices — and a reminder that what looks like a messy, imperfect result may actually contain hidden order worth investigating.