A new study from Dartmouth College suggests that the secret to enjoyable conversation may lie in a pattern known as "pink noise" — a balance between sticking with a topic long enough to learn from each other and switching to something new before the exchange grows stale. The research, published in Science Advances, offers a mathematical framework for understanding what makes people feel they "click" during a discussion and could have implications for students navigating everything from group projects to networking events.

According to the Dartmouth team, conversations that exhibit more pink noise tend to be rated as more enjoyable by participants. "When people talk about good conversation, they often use metaphors like 'in sync' or 'being on the same wavelength' that break down when we consider them in mathematical terms," said Katie O'Nell, the study's first author and a doctoral candidate in psychological and brain sciences at Dartmouth. "We show that over-synchronization is probably a bad thing and that moving both toward and away from each other can help conversationalists feel like they click."

The researchers used transformer neural networks — the same type of software behind chatbots like ChatGPT — to convert transcripts from nearly 1,700 conversations from an open-source dataset called the CANDOR corpus into a numerical map. In this map, each person's turn to speak became a data point, with similar sentences clustered nearby and dissimilar ones placed farther apart. The team then measured how far each part of a conversation was from the one before it, rendering these distances as signals similar to sound waves. They tested whether each signal resembled red, white, or pink noise.

Red noise is low-frequency and muffled, like the distant roar of the ocean, while white noise is sharp and high-frequency, like a television with no signal. Pink noise sits between the two, with a consistent sound energy similar to a steady waterfall. "I think of pink noise as a 'Goldilocks signal' between red and white noise," said Emily Finn, the study's corresponding author and an assistant professor of psychological and brain sciences at Dartmouth. "Pink noise exists in the middle of these two types of signals, balancing the slow, stable meandering of red noise with the quick, jumpy movements of white noise. It gives you some amount of stability, while also allowing you to make a change when you need to."

In conversational terms, the researchers describe white-noise dialogue as rambling with no particular focus — like talking to a toddler — while red-noise conversation is intensely focused and unyielding, resembling an unfriendly legal deposition. Pink-noise conversation, by contrast, involves speakers adapting to each other, finding adjacent topics that allow the exchange to continue smoothly. O'Nell gave an example: one speaker says, "I'm a huge baseball fan," to which the other replies, "I like basketball better myself." The first speaker then says, "My son does too, it's faster paced," and the other responds, "Exactly! Does your son play any sports?"

"They're adapting to each other," O'Nell explained. "The second person isn't a fan of basketball but doesn't just dead-end the conversation or move to a different topic. He finds something adjacent in his enjoyment of a different sport that allows the other speaker to find her own connection. He then latches onto the topic of her son to learn more about her since it's clear they're not going to talk about sports teams at length."

The dataset also included post-conversation surveys, which allowed the team to confirm that the amount of pink noise in a conversation accurately predicted how much participants said they enjoyed the exchange and felt connected to their conversation partner. The researchers then tested their findings on transcripts from a speed-dating podcast and reported that first-date conversations with more pink noise were more likely to lead to a second date.

Importantly, the study suggests that pink noise is not just an innate talent. An evaluation of 25 podcasts with dual hosts revealed that pink noise increased over the first 50 episodes for nearly all pairs of speakers. "This result is particularly interesting because it suggests that coordinating our words in a way that results in pink noise might be a learnable skill," O'Nell said. "Anyone who's suffered through an awkward conversation on a date or at the Thanksgiving table may have a reason for hope. People may be able to move towards pinker conversations with practice."

Finn offered practical advice for students and others looking to improve their conversational skills. "Our findings suggest that if you've stayed on a topic for long enough that it's feeling tedious, don't be afraid to inject some randomness and search for a new topic together," she said. "If you're bouncing between topics more quickly than you'd like, take a moment to reflect on what your partner is saying and ask follow-up questions."

The Dartmouth study — which also includes co-author Kiara Sanchez, a former assistant professor of psychological and brain sciences — is distinct from existing research on conversational dynamics because it emphasizes the importance of divergence, not just synchronization. Most other studies focus on how speakers become more similar to each other over time. "By invoking this idea of pink noise, we're able to show how important it is for people to break away from each other as well," O'Nell said. "After all, speaking to a parrot would result in perfect alignment, but be a terrible conversation."

Finn added that the team hopes the work opens up more research into improving human communication, especially around difficult topics. "We're hoping our work opens up more research into how to improve human communication, especially around difficult topics," she said.