A new study led by Nanyang Technological University (NTU) Singapore suggests that hostility in online discussions about heatwaves may spread like a contagion, with uncivil comments more likely to attract uncivil replies. The findings, published in the journal Environmental Communication on 11 November, point to the potential value of early intervention to prevent hostile exchanges from escalating, particularly as global climate talks at COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, put the integrity of climate information on the agenda.
Researchers analysed more than 19,000 posts and comments about heatwaves on Reddit, drawn from eight communities covering climate change, environmental issues and regions affected by extreme heat. The dataset, primarily in English and published between 2023 and 2024, included 1,369 original posts, 10,800 direct replies and 7,297 subsequent replies. Using AI-assisted natural language processing, the team examined forms of incivility, emotions expressed and discussion themes.
According to NTU, only 9.4 per cent of original posts contained incivility, compared with 35.9 per cent of direct replies and 35.4 per cent of subsequent replies. The most common form of incivility was aspersion — disparaging remarks directed at ideas, positions or behaviour — detected in about one in four replies, more prevalent than name-calling or vulgarity.
The study found that uncivil comments were more likely to be followed by uncivil replies, a pattern consistent with a contagion effect. In contrast, negative emotions such as anger, disgust and sadness expressed in earlier comments showed little link to later hostility. The researchers say this suggests people may be mirroring the behaviour they encounter online, although the study cannot establish cause and effect.
Professor Shirley Ho, President's Chair in Communication Studies at NTU’s Wee Kim Wee School of Communication and Information and senior author of the study, said: “COP31 has put the importance of reliable climate information in the spotlight. But getting the science right is only part of effective climate communication. People also need to be able to discuss difficult questions about climate change without conversations turning hostile. Hostility matters because it could distract people from engaging with the evidence, understanding different perspectives and discussing possible solutions.”
The study also found that incivility was associated with certain topics, including contested issues such as the human causes of climate change, political and economic views of climate change, and topics tied to lived experiences of extreme heat, such as heatwaves in India and Texas, housing, transport and city design. These findings suggest that discussions about climate responsibility and the consequences of extreme heat can be particularly contentious.
Dr Joseph Simons, Principal Scientist at A*STAR Institute of Advanced Intelligence and Computing and co-author of the study, said: “Looking at individual comments tells us how common online hostility is, but not how it unfolds across a conversation. By using AI to analyse thousands of posts and replies, we were able to identify patterns of incivility across different stages of online discussions. These insights could help social media platforms develop smarter moderation tools that help identify emerging patterns of hostility and enable earlier, more targeted intervention.”
The researchers suggest that social media platforms could intervene early by identifying highly uncivil comments before they attract further replies and temporarily reducing their visibility, or by prompting users to reconsider aggressive language before posting. For climate communicators, the study suggests that placing greater emphasis on the benefits of climate action, rather than focusing mainly on contentious questions such as the causes of climate change, may help reduce triggers of incivility.
Assistant Professor Nova Huang of Jinan University and first author of the study said: “Online discussions are now an important place where people make sense of climate change. If hostility becomes the norm in these spaces, it may crowd out the exchange of evidence and perspectives that public deliberation depends on. The challenge is not to avoid contentious issues, but to find ways to discuss them constructively. Our study points to where efforts might begin, but testing which approaches actually work will be an important next step.”
The study was conducted by researchers from NTU Singapore; the Agency for Science, Technology and Research (A*STAR); Jinan University, China; and Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand.