A new study published in Science reveals that Indonesia's pulp and paper sector, which had nearly eliminated deforestation linked to its supply chains by 2017, is now reversing course. According to the research, led by Robert Heilmayr of UC Santa Barbara's Environmental Markets Lab (emLab), the area of forest converted to pulpwood plantations grew from roughly 13,838 acres in 2017 to 60,047 acres in 2022, representing a more than fourfold rise. By 2022, pulpwood-driven forest clearing exceeded that for industrial oil palm, a crop that has attracted significantly more international scrutiny for its role in deforestation and peatland destruction in Indonesia.
The study, which involved an international team of researchers from Indonesia, the United States, France, and Spain, used satellite imagery and supply-chain records to track forest loss and plantation expansion from 2001 to 2022. The researchers mapped where industrial acacia and eucalyptus plantations replaced natural forests and peatlands, and traced which concessions supply which mills. They found that more than half of the pulp-driven clearing between 2015 and 2022 occurred on land they suspect is controlled by the parent groups of Asia Pulp & Paper (APP) and Asia Pacific Resources International Limited (APRIL), the two companies that had pledged to end deforestation in their supply chains in 2013 and 2015, respectively.
"Ownership in this sector can be hard to untangle," said co-author Timer Manurung, executive director of Auriga Nusantara, an Indonesian NGO. "Tracing which concessions supply which mills, and who ultimately controls them, is essential for knowing whether zero-deforestation commitments are being met."
The study highlights how a combination of factors drove the initial decline in deforestation between 2011 and 2017, when pulp-linked deforestation fell by 95%. Those factors included international incentives, domestic government reforms to protect forests and peatlands, productivity improvements that allowed existing plantations to produce more wood per hectare, and the zero-deforestation pledges from APP and APRIL. Together, those pledges made Indonesia's pulp sector the first tropical commodity in which all national production was covered by such commitments.
But the researchers caution that the progress is fragile. Pressure on forests is likely to intensify as the industry expands pulp mill capacity by nearly 80% to meet growing demand. Even if plantations continue to improve productivity, the team estimates the expansion could drive roughly 345,947 additional acres of deforestation — an area larger than the city of Los Angeles — and convert nearly 494,210 acres of peatland.
Recent policy changes may worsen the situation. A sweeping 2020 deregulation law rolled back many environmental protections, and the country issued new licenses that could open selectively logged forests to full plantation conversion. Additionally, APP and APRIL last year shifted their zero-deforestation cut-off dates from 2013 and 2015 to the end of 2020, meaning suppliers that cleared forest during those intervening years are now deemed compliant with the pledges. The researchers say these changes undermine the credibility of the commitments.
"The current expansion of Indonesia's pulp industry involves several billion dollars of capital investment in new production capacity," said Christopher Barr of the nonprofit group Woods & Wayside International. "This will put enormous long-term pressures on forests and peatlands to deliver the massive increases in wood these mills will consume — and these pressures will compete directly with the companies' zero-deforestation commitments."
The stakes extend beyond Indonesia. Converting peatlands to plantations makes them more vulnerable to burning, which releases large amounts of stored carbon and produces smoke that has caused devastating health impacts across Southeast Asia. In 2015, one of the worst fire seasons on record burned more than 6.4 million acres.
"Indonesia's pulp sector shows both that ending deforestation is possible, but that this progress is fragile," Heilmayr said. "Keeping forests and peatlands intact will take sustained effort from governments, companies and the buyers of paper and viscose products."
The team plans to investigate whether companies may be sidestepping their pledges, focusing on ownership and sourcing relationships that can obscure responsibility for clearing, and on loopholes in the zero-deforestation commitments themselves.