A new analysis from the Blavatnik School of Government at the University of Oxford warns that a growing divide in global trade policies on clean energy technologies is making the shift away from fossil fuels slower and more expensive. The report, based on fresh data from the Oxford Climate Policy Monitor, tracks how 31 countries—representing 90% of global GDP—are handling imports of electric vehicles (EVs), batteries, wind turbines, and solar panels.

According to the analysis by Professor Thomas Hale and Dr. Claas Mertens, two opposing trends have emerged over the past year. On one side, major economies are moving toward more protectionist trade policies on clean tech. On the other, many smaller economies are reducing trade barriers to make these technologies more affordable.

Dr. Mertens, a Leverhulme Early Career Fellow at the Blavatnik School, explained the core tension: "China has established a commanding position in the global clean technology market: in 2025, it produced around 75% of the world's electric cars, more than 80% of its battery cells and 79% of its solar panels." He noted that China's dominance has helped drive down the cost of renewable energy, but governments are now worried about becoming too dependent on a single supplier, especially after the energy shocks from the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine and the 2026 US–Israeli war against Iran.

The report, published ahead of COP31, highlights that trade in clean technology has become a flashpoint. China is calling for the free flow of green technology, while many of its trading partners are restricting imports.

Diverging approaches

The United States has imposed tariffs of 100% on Chinese EVs, along with substantial duties on batteries and solar technologies. The European Union has imposed duties on Chinese electric cars, and countries including India, Canada, and Türkiye have introduced measures targeting Chinese products.

In contrast, a different group of countries—including Argentina, Australia, Costa Rica, Egypt, the Philippines, South Korea, and Thailand—have introduced measures to encourage imports of EVs or renewable energy equipment. The UK has also taken steps toward greater openness by removing import duties on components used in offshore wind projects.

The authors describe these liberalising nations as creating an informal free trade area for clean technologies, even though they are not part of a formal trade agreement. However, the liberalisers outside China itself are mostly smaller economies that together account for only around 8% of global GDP. In contrast, those countries that have introduced at least some restrictions account for 58% of global GDP.

The largest group of countries mixes approaches. Indonesia temporarily eliminated import tariffs on completely built electric vehicles for companies that pledged to manufacture a matching quantity of cars within the country. Nigeria and Kenya have implemented measures aimed at promoting access to green technologies while bolstering local production and assembly. Brazil is limiting imports of fully assembled goods while easing restrictions on component imports, opening the way for home-assembled final technologies.

A balancing act

Professor Thomas Hale said: "When governments think about clean technologies, they are navigating between three goals—effective climate policy, economic growth, and geoeconomic security. The solution lies in combining international trade with targeted support for domestic industries and safeguards against the use of technology supplies as a source of geopolitical pressure."

He added that approaches by Indonesia, Nigeria, Kenya, and others suggest governments do not necessarily have to choose between completely open markets and extensive trade barriers.

Dr. Mertens proposed that China might alleviate worries over reliance through overseas manufacturing investments, technology transfers, and trustworthy guarantees of future supply. At the same time, bigger economies could adopt targeted steps to strengthen their economic security instead of trying to create fully independent clean energy sectors.

"Diversified international partnerships coupled with leadership in selected areas will go a long way," he said. "Smaller countries could specialise in particular stages of manufacturing, allowing them to participate in global supply chains without having to produce every component themselves. Our findings show that many countries have begun to implement this strategy."

The authors argue that international cooperation could help prevent economic rivalry from obstructing the transition to cleaner energy. This could include agreements to reduce tariffs on selected clean technologies and safeguards against countries deliberately restricting supplies for geopolitical advantage. "None of this requires a grand bargain, and the data suggest the pieces are at hand," they said.

They also noted that "transparency is a precondition: few governments or observers have a cross-country view of these measures. The Climate Policy Monitor's trade data can serve as a shared baseline for the policy decisions ahead."