A new systematic scoping review published in Frontiers in Public Health has found that hearing screening programs for preschool- and school-aged children vary dramatically across the globe, with inconsistent protocols, low follow-up rates, and limited adoption of existing guidelines hampering efforts to identify and manage childhood hearing loss.
The review, led by researchers from the Medical University of South Carolina, Alexandria University, and the World Health Organization, analyzed 65 original research articles from 30 countries spanning all six WHO regions. The studies covered screening approaches for children aged 2 to 19 years, with the goal of providing a contemporary snapshot of global practices.
According to the review, pure-tone audiometry remained the most common screening tool, used in 92.3% of studies. Otoscopy and otoacoustic emissions (OAEs) were also widely employed. However, the authors noted a notable shift toward low-cost technology: 18 studies used mobile phone or tablet applications for screening, and two employed telehealth-based approaches, particularly in resource-limited settings.
Screening failure rates varied widely, ranging from 1.2% to 49.2%, and diagnostic follow-up rates were inconsistent, spanning 10% to 100%. The review found that follow-up was often hindered by parental perceptions and access barriers. True prevalence estimates of hearing loss were limited by this inconsistency in follow-up diagnostic testing.
Commonly reported causes of hearing loss included addressable conditions such as cerumen impaction (earwax buildup), otitis media (middle ear infection), and other middle ear diseases. The WHO estimates that 34 million children globally are affected by disabling hearing loss, and that 80% of individuals with hearing loss live in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), where access to ear and hearing care is limited.
The review highlighted significant challenges in implementation, adaptation, and standardization of hearing screening programs. Few guidelines for systematic hearing screening were identified, and compliance with existing recommendations was limited. The authors noted that while newborn hearing screening is critical, delayed-onset, progressive, or acquired hearing loss can present in older children, necessitating additional screening during childhood.
School-based screening was described as potentially efficient and effective, given that many countries require participation in early education. The review also noted that systematic hearing screening may be implemented alongside other screenings, such as vision, to improve cost-effectiveness and efficiency.
For university students studying fields such as public health, audiology, or global health, the review underscores the persistent disparities in healthcare access and the need for standardized, scalable screening programs. The findings also highlight opportunities for innovation in low-cost technology and telehealth, which could be relevant for students interested in health technology or international development.
The review's protocol is registered in the Open Science Framework (registration: osf.io/whky8/).