According to a study led by researchers at the University of Texas at Austin, the fossilized remains of ancient coral reefs, often found just meters from living corals in the Caribbean, could provide crucial insights into where corals might survive a warming future. The findings, published in the journals PALAIOS and Conservation Biology, focus on reefs in northeastern Jamaica and aim to guide rehabilitation efforts in a region where coral cover has declined sharply over the past 70 years.

Claire Williams, who led the research while earning a doctorate at the UT Jackson School of Geosciences, explained that studying already damaged modern reefs provides a limited baseline for what a healthy reef once looked like. "So, my theory was that by bringing in the fossil record, we could get a richer picture of coral tolerances and make better predictions for the future," Williams said in a statement from the university.

The team analyzed fossil reefs dating back 125,000 to 130,000 years to the Late Pleistocene epoch, a period known for interglacial warming. Williams noted that these past warming periods are good analogs for what the planet is projected to experience in about 50 to 100 years. The fossil reefs are now above sea level, so researchers adapted a transect method typically used to monitor modern corals—walking along the fossils and photographing them to estimate the number and distribution of coral species in an area. They then compared this data with modern reef sites.

At the modern sites, the researchers found that certain branching corals called Acropora—including Acropora palmata and Acropora cervicornis—which were abundant during the Pleistocene, are now largely dead and covered by algae. Most remaining corals are Porites astreoides, a globular species that Williams said can recover quickly after disturbances but does not provide helpful reef structure. "These big branching species provide a lot of habitat and offshore protection. With that gone, we've lost that function on the reef," Williams said.

Co-author Rowan Martindale, an associate professor at the Jackson School's Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, cautioned that simply planting more Acropora corals in degraded environments is not a straightforward solution. "We can nurture and transplant new, healthy corals from nurseries to damaged reefs, often referred to as coral gardening, but if they are in a place that's too hot in the future, they're not going to survive," Martindale said. The researchers noted that many corals transplanted by the Alligator Head Foundation, a marine conservation group in East Portland, Jamaica, died during a heat-induced bleaching event in the summer of 2023.

To address this, the researchers conducted a study on the ecological niches of ancient corals, analyzing the water temperature and salinity they could tolerate. They included data from mid-Holocene fossil records, dating back 5,000 to 7,000 years, to get more recent data points. This data was used to predict places with similar ecological niches to past environments, helping to indicate where species might survive in the future. The researchers also incorporated climate model data to identify reef areas in the Caribbean projected to have suitable salinity and sea-surface temperature for species that can foster healthy reef ecosystems. The best spots for conservation include parts of the northern Caribbean, the Florida Keys, and the Yucatan Peninsula.

Williams emphasized that the findings should be considered a starting point. Environments need consistent monitoring for issues such as disease, pollution, natural disasters, and other environmental problems. "The fossil record can improve our predictions and provide best-case ideas of where things might be able to survive," Williams said. "Conservation needs to be adaptive and to keep learning new information."

Martindale added that protecting reef ecosystems is critical for human communities that depend on them. "There are people that need the reefs for fish and protection from hurricanes. You can't just abandon the places that rely on those functions," she said.

Williams, now a postdoctoral researcher at the Georgia Institute of Technology and Texas A&M University, collaborated with scientists from the Jackson School, the University of the West Indies, the Alligator Head Foundation, and the University of New Mexico. The research was funded by the National Science Foundation and UT Austin's Program in British, Irish and Empire Studies.