A new international treaty designed to protect Indigenous intellectual property could become ineffective if major economies do not join, according to an analysis by Mathew Kerwin, a First Nations Fellow at the Lowy Institute.

Australia is moving toward ratifying the World Intellectual Property Organisation's Intellectual Property, Genetic Resources and Associated Traditional Knowledge Treaty, which Kerwin describes as a milestone for Indigenous recognition in global intellectual property law. It is the first treaty to address the intersection of patents and traditional knowledge while including provisions specific to Indigenous peoples.

However, momentum has been slow. According to the Lowy Institute analysis, only four countries — Malawi, Uganda, Peru and Albania — have ratified the treaty so far. Without participation from major manufacturing economies, Kerwin warns that Australian ratification could place new compliance and disclosure obligations on small and medium-sized enterprises while doing little to constrain those operating outside the treaty.

Domestically, Australia's cultural policy "Revive" has focused on strengthening traditional knowledge protections through new legislation, bolstering the Indigenous Art Code, improving funding arrangements, and progressing work toward dedicated Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property legislation. These reforms respond in part to a 2022 Productivity Commission report, which found that two-thirds of "Indigenous-style" souvenirs sold in Australia were inauthentic and recommended stronger protections.

Yet past attempts at protection and certification schemes have introduced unforeseen burdens, the analysis notes. Fair trade certification, for example, was designed to protect producers squeezed out of the value of their own goods. In practice, the burden of proving compliance has fallen on producers themselves, who face intense scrutiny to maintain ethical standards. Verifying where a product actually originated and meeting technical standards can erode the competitiveness those deals were meant to create, particularly for smaller businesses least able to absorb the paperwork.

Recent analysis by Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation similarly notes that restrictive rules of origin can challenge micro, small, and medium-sized enterprises with limited capacity to manage complex compliance requirements.

Tensions are already visible in Indigenous cultural industries. Indigenous-owned enterprises often shoulder the expenses of preserving cultural legitimacy and genuineness when they face competition from fake Aboriginal-style goods made or marketed overseas. As an instance, Yidaki (didgeridoos) tied to Yolngu stewardship are recognized as being manufactured, instructed and sold globally by individuals who have minimal or no ties to the communities that are the source of the instrument.

In 2019, the Federal Court ordered Queensland-based company Birubi Art Pty Ltd to pay $2.3 million in penalties after it was found to have misled consumers by selling products described as "Aboriginal Art" that were manufactured in Indonesia. In 1991, the clothing manufacturer Dolina Fashion Group Pty Ltd supplied Grace Bros stores with an "exclusive" dress design for a major promotion, with allegations that Dolina's stylists had requested an Aboriginal look from a Japanese fabric maker. A decade ago, the misuse of the Wandjina spirit by a non-Indigenous artist demonstrated how customary restrictions may not be recognised under conventional intellectual property law.

The treaty may contain a blind spot, according to Kerwin, one that could turn a miracle into a mirage. The treaty's disclosure requirements address longstanding concerns about the use of genetic resources and associated traditional knowledge in patent applications. But genetic resources and traditional knowledge are progressively being digitised, shared and reused without anyone interacting with the communities from which they originated.

Consider a scenario where a drug firm must reveal where it obtained a genetic material or related Indigenous knowledge for its studies; however, after that data is converted into sequences, turned digital, and disseminated, uncertainties arise regarding the ongoing application of transparency, credit, and profit-sharing requirements..

Emerging AI technologies further risk amplifying this dynamic. AI systems can reproduce and commercialise Indigenous cultural expressions without engaging the communities from which they originate, raising questions of attribution, consent and benefit-sharing as cultural value becomes economic value. More recently, Wandjina imagery has again appeared in social media posts identified as AI-generated and not created in Australia, causing considerable distress to the Mowanjum community and underlining the continued challenge of protecting culturally significant material once it moves beyond traditional custodial control.

"The challenge for policymakers is not necessarily the number of rules, but whether they can be enforced consistently and applied broadly enough to avoid creating incentives for free riding," Kerwin writes.

Ratification of the traditional knowledge treaty strengthens the case for Australian domestic policy reforms by linking Australia's domestic arrangements to emerging international obligations. But getting major manufacturing economies to participate in the treaty will also be key, the analysis concludes.