A new study from Université de Montréal reveals that Canada's largest cities have a long way to go before their residential neighbourhoods can be considered truly green, according to a benchmark known as the 3-30-300 rule.

The rule, increasingly used by urban planners, sets three simple targets: residents should be able to see at least three mature trees from their home, live in a neighbourhood with at least 30 per cent tree canopy cover, and be within 300 metres of a large public green space.

Researchers led by Audrey Smargiassi, a professor at UdeM's School of Public Health, used airborne LiDAR data to examine more than 10,000 residential areas in Montreal, Quebec City, Toronto, Ottawa and Vancouver. Their findings were published this month in the journal Urban Forestry & Urban Greening.

According to the study, the first criterion — seeing at least three trees at least 10 metres tall from home — was met in 55.5 to 92.6 per cent of neighbourhoods, depending on the city. Access to parks within 300 metres was lower, ranging from 39.8 to 54.7 per cent of neighbourhoods. But canopy cover was the biggest shortfall: only 0.8 to 7.4 per cent of neighbourhoods reached the 30 per cent threshold.

When all three criteria were considered together, very few neighbourhoods — between 0.6 and 3.4 per cent — met the full 3-30-300 rule when only mature trees at least 10 metres tall were counted.

Smargiassi told UdeMNouvelles that the precision of LiDAR was important because not all trees contribute equally to canopy cover. "While a young, newly planted tree holds promise for the future, it lacks the broad, shady canopy of a mature tree," she said.

The study also highlighted a spatial mismatch: several cities have high overall tree cover, but those trees are concentrated on the outskirts, away from where most people live. "A large, wooded area on the edge of a city can push up the city's average, but those trees aren't providing any shade in more densely populated neighbourhoods," Smargiassi noted.

Montreal illustrated this paradox clearly. The city ranked last among the five for both the three-tree visibility rule and the 300-metre park access rule, yet scored highest for 30 per cent canopy cover — because its heavily wooded eastern and western ends are sparsely populated.

Compounding the challenge, the City of Montreal announced in September 2026 that it was cutting funding for tree planting, combating the emerald ash borer, and controlling invasive species. Smargiassi said that while scaling back new planting is disappointing, failing to protect existing mature trees is worse. "A newly planted tree takes years, even decades, to reach a size where it can provide a substantial canopy and benefit residents," she explained.

Smargiassi stressed that the 3-30-300 rule is not a precise scientific threshold but a memorable target for comparing cities and identifying neighbourhoods most in need of more greenery. The next step for researchers is to better understand how urban greenery affects health and well-being, including stress reduction, cooling, and encouraging physical activity.

"The challenge isn't just to make cities greener on a map," she said, "but to ensure that nature takes root where people live."