The European Commission’s proposed Cloud and AI Development Act (CADA) is meant to reduce the EU’s reliance on non-European technology providers, but researchers at the University of Amsterdam’s Institute for Information Law (IViR) say the plan is not ambitious enough to achieve genuine digital autonomy.
According to the IViR team, the European cloud market is heavily concentrated: three US-based companies control more than 70% of the market, and the EU spends roughly €264 billion each year on IT products and services that are predominantly American. The CADA aims to counter this by making large-scale data centre investment more attractive, cutting administrative red tape, simplifying permit processes, and introducing rules for how public sector bodies buy cloud services.
In a position paper published on 13 November 2026, the researchers argue that the proposal as drafted could actually limit public authorities’ ability to reduce their dependence on a small number of outside providers. Kristina Irion, one of the co-authors, said the legislation could undermine Dutch efforts to achieve greater digital sovereignty and reduce reliance on Big Tech, at a time when the Netherlands is already taking steps in that direction.
“As currently drafted, the EU proposal could even prevent public sector organisations from consciously choosing a European alternative,” Irion said.
The researchers also contend that the planned expansion of data centre capacity does not automatically translate into greater digital autonomy. Co-author Plixavra Vogiatzoglou noted that under the current proposal, “providers and developers from outside the EU would retain a strong foothold.”
Beyond the question of market concentration, the IViR team said the CADA gives too little attention to sustainability and the interests of local communities. They argue that genuine digital autonomy requires more than just additional data centres.
“Greater digital autonomy also requires clear sustainability rules, democratic participation, stronger public procurement requirements and more support for European and open alternatives,” Irion said.
The position paper, titled “The EU’s Proposal for a Cloud and AI Development Act: Not the Industrial Policy the EU Needs,” was authored by Plixavra Vogiatzoglou, Kristina Irion, Anushka Mittal, Laurens Naudts, and Charis Papaevangelou. It was published by the Institute for Information Law at the University of Amsterdam.
For university students across Europe, the findings are relevant on several fronts. Many students rely on cloud-based tools and AI services for their studies, and the dominance of non-European providers raises questions about data privacy, cost, and the long-term viability of European alternatives. The researchers’ critique also touches on the environmental impact of data centre expansion, a concern that resonates with students on campuses where sustainability is a growing priority. If the CADA does not adequately address these issues, students may find themselves using services that do not align with their values or that fail to protect their data as robustly as European alternatives might.
Moreover, the debate over digital autonomy has implications for students studying computer science, information law, or public policy. The CADA’s shortcomings, as identified by the IViR team, could shape the regulatory environment in which these students will eventually work. The researchers’ call for stronger public procurement rules and support for European alternatives suggests that future graduates may need to navigate a more complex landscape of regulations and market dynamics.
The IViR analysis is based on a review of the proposed legislation and does not include input from the European Commission or industry stakeholders. As such, the findings represent one academic perspective on a policy that is still in development. The researchers’ concerns, however, highlight a gap between the EU’s stated goals and the mechanisms proposed to achieve them.