According to a new study published in the American Journal of Biological Anthropology by researchers from the University of St Andrews, Dartmouth College, the University of Konstanz, the Max Planck Institute of Animal Behaviour, and African Parks, eagles are preying on adult male baboons that weigh well over 26kg — within the size range of early human ancestors. The discovery upends a long-standing assumption in evolutionary biology that primates of that size were too heavy for even the largest eagles to lift.
The baboons live on the Ennedi plateau in northern Chad, an isolated population of primates in the middle of the Sahara Desert. The team found skulls and bones of adult male baboons bearing the signature marks of eagle predation: talon punctures to the skull and characteristic scrapes and rakes on the shoulder bones. One individual weighed more than 26kg, far exceeding the previous 13kg threshold above which no primate was thought to be vulnerable to raptor attacks.
Lead author Professor Catherine Hobaiter, from the School of Psychology and Neuroscience at the University of St Andrews, described the expedition as "any primatologist's dream." She noted that some of the baboons are so remote they rarely see people, and after a few days they began following the researchers around. "We saw the eagles while we were searching for the baboons, but we never imagined that they might be a threat to them. Then we found the first skull with a puncture mark, and then another, and another," she said.
Senior author Professor Nathaniel Dominy from Dartmouth College said the idea initially seemed improbable. "At first, the idea of eagles hunting adult male baboons seemed to exist on the thin edge of possibility, until it didn't. Our scepticism slowly gave way to acceptance. The evidence was convincing."
The finding has significant implications for understanding human evolution. While hominins were known to be vulnerable to land-based predators such as big cats and crocodiles, defence strategies against aerial predators are quite different. Primates typically respond to eagle attacks by "mobbing" — larger adult males charge the attacker to drive it off. Knowing that our ancestors may have been vulnerable to eagles changes how scientists think about the evolution of key behaviours, from communication to group cooperation.
Modern primates that live in areas with eagle predators often move in large mixed groups with other primate species. For most of our evolutionary history, early humans lived alongside other hominin species and other primates. These groups are often thought of as competitors, but the new evidence suggests there may have been cooperative advantages to sticking together.
Professor Hobaiter highlighted one particularly telling observation: the baboons responded specifically to Verreaux's eagles, not to other large birds of prey. "Primates are very specific about only responding to eagles that are a genuine threat. We'd seen them very relaxed around other big birds of prey, but as soon as the Verreaux came into view they alarm called and dropped down to safety."
Dr Gisela Kopp, from the University of Konstanz and the Max Planck Institute of Animal Behavior, noted that primatology often focuses on regions with high primate diversity, but shifting attention to a place where no primatological data had ever been collected proved extremely rewarding.
Dr Jean Didier Akpona, from African Parks, who had worked in the region for about three years, said he had often observed Verreaux's eagles at the gueltas — pockets of water that form within rock formations. "I had never imagined that these predators would target primates of this size until the research team stumbled upon evidence. This discovery leads us to explore further the mystery that surrounds the gueltas of the Sahara Desert."
The team plans to continue studying the Ennedi baboons. Professor Hobaiter said the first observations from Ennedi have already upended many assumptions about what these baboons should be doing, from their diet to their social lives. "I can't wait to see what new 'rules' they'll break next!"