A new research project at Cornell University aims to close a critical gap in monitoring how antibiotics are used in dairy cows, poultry and companion animals, potentially helping animal caretakers make more informed treatment decisions and reducing the spread of antibiotic-resistant bacteria. The five-year effort is supported by a $7.5 million grant from the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), according to the Cornell Chronicle.
The stakes are high. Resistant bacteria, often called superbugs, could jeopardize food security for more than 2 billion people and add $159 billion to annual healthcare costs by 2050, the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation has projected. Superbugs arise when antibiotics kill susceptible bacteria but leave resistant ones to survive and multiply. Those resistant bacteria can transfer to people through food, contact with animals and the environment, in addition to resistance driven by antibiotic use in humans.
But tracking antibiotic use in animals is notoriously difficult. Farmers and veterinarians have been reluctant to share data, and measurement standards vary widely, the Cornell Chronicle reported. The main source of antimicrobial use data today comes from pharmaceutical companies reporting sales figures by tonnage — a very imprecise metric for understanding how and why antibiotics are actually used.
"We cannot manage how antimicrobials are used in animals unless we can measure, and we cannot measure because data are fragmented, siloed and unstandardized and there are no incentives for data sharing, and so there are these big hurdles about trust," said Dr. Renata Ivanek, professor of population medicine and diagnostic sciences in the College of Veterinary Medicine and the grant's principal investigator, as quoted by the Cornell Chronicle.
Ivanek said the project's big goal is to make measurement possible by addressing the lack of reliable standardization and shareable information, integrating advanced privacy-protected technologies for data sharing and stakeholder-centered governance.
The team plans to develop a secure data repository that aggregates antimicrobial use statistics while keeping individual information private and confidential. A dashboard showing average national and local antimicrobial use could help farmers and veterinarians make smarter decisions about treating their animals.
One major hurdle is low trust. Farmers and veterinarians worry they might be criticized or judged by peers, government regulators, consumers and clients regarding perceived overuse or underuse of antimicrobials — judgments that can be misinterpreted when outsiders don't know the full context behind treatment decisions.
"Government officials would like to know how much antimicrobials are used to get a handle on stewardship to curb resistance," Ivanek said. "And consumers are very invested in how food is produced. Some consumers do not want any antibiotics used on animals. At the same time, pet owners naturally expect the best care for their pets and may advocate using antibiotics."
To protect privacy, project leaders plan to provide participants with a computer model that aggregates information at the data source itself, then returns only the aggregated data to a central repository. The project aims to collect multiple data streams from dairy and poultry farmers and companion animal veterinarians, and eventually from beef and swine producers as well, to break up information silos and compile a more complete picture.
In return for sharing data, approved users could get actionable information — for example, seeing how their antimicrobial use compares to a national average, which could guide appropriate treatment decisions. The information may also point to areas where more research is needed, Ivanek said.
The grant will also address standardizing metrics. Currently, antibiotic use is measured in milligrams, doses, or even as a number of veterinary visits for treatments — each capturing an incomplete picture. The project team will explore implementing a novel, standard metric that can be used across various sectors. The co-principal investigators are Dr. Daryl Nydam and Dr. Casey Cazer from the College of Veterinary Medicine; Steven Wolf, Kurt Waldman, and danah boyd from the College of Agriculture and Life Sciences; Daniel Susser, Hakim Weatherspoon, Christopher De Sa, Immanuel Trummer, and Jennifer Sun from Cornell Bowers Computing and Information Science; Dr. Randall Singer of Mindwalk Consulting Group, LLC; and Dr. Jennifer Granick from the University of Minnesota.