According to a blog post by Jason Furman, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics (PIIE), the U.S. economy may be more resilient to a stock market crash than many fear. Furman's analysis, published on November 17, 2026, examines the potential economic fallout if the current AI-driven stock market boom turns out to be a bubble that bursts.
Furman, who served as chair of the White House Council of Economic Advisers under President Obama, argues that the so-called "wealth effect" — the tendency for consumers to spend more when their stock portfolios rise and cut back when they fall — is likely to be muted in the current environment. He estimates that households have spent only about 1 cent of every dollar of their recent stock market gains, far less than the historical average of about 3 cents per dollar.
"Consumers, in aggregate, have been surprisingly prudent in spending the recent stock increases," Furman writes. This means they would not need to cut their spending back dramatically on the way down.
The analysis considers three hypothetical scenarios for a stock market decline: a 25 percent drop (the "baseline"), a 35 percent drop (the "bad case"), and a 50 percent drop (the "severe case"). Furman notes that market pricing puts the probability of a 25 percent decline sustained through the end of 2027 at less than 10 percent, and the chance of a 50 percent decline at about 2 percent.
Under his preferred specification, Furman estimates that consumer spending cutbacks from a stock market crash would reduce economic growth by about 0.6 percentage point over the next year. He views a larger impact — up to 3.4 percentage points — as a "very remote tail risk" that would occur solely through the wealth effect on consumption.
Furman points to historical precedent to support his view. He notes that the 2001 recession, which followed the bursting of the dot-com bubble, was "the least consumer-driven recession in both relative and absolute terms in the postwar period." Consumer spending slowed but never went negative, growing 1.8 percent during its worst four quarters. The recession was primarily driven by a dramatic reduction in business investment, not consumer cutbacks.
Similarly, after the 1987 stock market crash — a 20.5 percent one-day decline in the S&P 500 — real GDP grew 3.8 percent and real consumer spending grew 4.6 percent in the following year. Furman notes that the Federal Reserve's immediate promise to provide liquidity helped, a factor that could be operative again today.
One reason for the limited consumer impact, Furman suggests, is that stock market wealth is highly concentrated. In mid-2026, the top 0.1 percent of households owned 25 percent of stocks and mutual funds held outside 401(k)s and pensions, and the top 10 percent owned 88 percent. The wealthiest households are unlikely to dramatically cut their spending if the market falls, because their consumption is not closely tied to their stock holdings.
"To take an extreme example, according to Forbes the wealth of the 10 richest Americans in fall 2026 is $2.5 trillion higher than it was in fall 2019," Furman writes. "While we do not have data on their consumption, I am willing to bet they did not increase their annual consumption expenditures by $7 billion each (which is 3 percent of their average wealth gain). Similarly, if the market crashes, they will not cut their spending by anything like that amount."
Furman also notes that the stock market is not the only source of wealth. Housing is even more important for the majority of households, and since 1976 the correlation between real changes in stock prices and house prices over a year has been just 0.16. His analysis models only stock market declines without considering any propagation or mitigation through the housing market.
For university students, the analysis offers a relatively reassuring outlook. While a stock market crash could affect job prospects, internship availability, and the value of any investments, the direct impact on consumer spending — and thus on the broader economy — is expected to be modest. Students should be aware that the biggest risk may not be a consumer-led recession but rather a downturn driven by business investment, which could affect hiring in sectors like technology and finance.
Furman's post is the third in a planned series of five examining the vulnerability of the economy to a collapse in what he calls an "AI bubble." Future posts will look at the broader financial system and the system's shock absorbers.