Governments worldwide are adopting carbon credit policies at an unprecedented rate, but these markets will only fulfil their potential if the underlying rules are given binding legal force and aligned with high-integrity standards, according to a new analysis from the Blavatnik School of Government at the University of Oxford.
Carbon credits allow companies to offset their greenhouse gas emissions by purchasing credits from projects that reduce or remove emissions — for example, protecting a forest from deforestation or restoring a peatland. Each credit represents one tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent. The credits are increasingly integrated into carbon markets, where emissions carry a financial price and participants can meet part of their obligations through credit purchases.
In principle, the system can channel finance toward environmental projects and poorer countries, letting businesses in wealthier, higher-emitting nations fund reforestation and conservation in developing nations. But the authors of the brief, Bhavya Gupta and Thomas Hale, argue that both demand and supply must be addressed.
On the demand side, buyers need to trust that a credit represents a real, durable tonne of emissions reduction and that using it carries no reputational or legal risk. Incidents such as forest fires that release stored carbon back into the atmosphere have undermined that trust. On the supply side, project developers need predictable demand to justify investing in long-term projects like afforestation.
“Clear, robust, and aligned rules on how carbon credits are generated, how they are used, and how they are exchanged” are essential, the authors write.
The analysis draws on data from the Oxford Climate Policy Monitor, which Thomas Hale co-leads. The Monitor, whose latest data was released during COP31 in November 2026, now tracks carbon crediting regulations across 39 countries representing 90% of global GDP. The number of carbon crediting policies has more than quadrupled since 2020, with 125 such policies in force by mid-2026 — 26 of them adopted since the start of 2025.
“This is now an active area of national policymaking, and several ‘coalitions of the willing’ are also working on making the carbon market more interoperable, so there can be global exchange at multiple levels,” said Bhavya Gupta, a postdoctoral research fellow at the Blavatnik School. “Their ultimate success depends on the quality of the underlying domestic rules they seek to build on and connect.”
The brief examines how far domestic regulation has come in creating conditions for a high-volume, high-integrity market, and where gaps remain. The authors say national governments need policies covering three stages of the carbon credit lifecycle: generation, use, and exchange.
Generation refers to projects that reduce or remove emissions — planting new forest, or protecting existing rainforest that might otherwise be cleared. Rules must ensure three things: that each credit represents a real, additional, and lasting tonne (not, for instance, protecting forest that was never at risk); that the risk of reversal is managed (e.g., protecting forests from wildfires); and that affected local communities are protected and share in the benefits (e.g., ensuring indigenous communities are not forcibly relocated).
“The basics are in place in the regulations we track, but in many countries reversal and social integrity are the weak links,” Gupta said.
Use is when companies buy credits to offset their own emissions. Rules here must create demand — giving companies a reason to buy credits, for example by allowing them to meet mandatory emissions limits — while also ensuring that credits do not divert companies from reducing their own emissions. The authors say demand is currently being created faster than guardrails.
Exchange covers the buying and selling of credits, which may cross borders. Rules must ensure each credit is tracked and counted only once, and that markets are transparent and well supervised. “The plumbing is in place for trading within countries, but cross-border integrity is missing,” Hale said. Most jurisdictions allow international transfers, but fewer explicitly require “corresponding adjustments” to prevent double-counting — where the same tonne is claimed by both the host country (e.g., Brazil protecting rainforest) and the buyer’s country (e.g., a UK company offsetting its travel).
The Oxford Climate Policy Monitor also tracks stringency — whether duties in a policy are mandatory, enforceable rules with meaningful penalties, rather than voluntary guidelines. The authors say this is the key area for improvement.
“There are a lot of good rules,” Hale said. “Our message to governments is that giving them binding force should now be the top priority.”
For university students studying environmental policy, economics, or international relations, the analysis highlights a critical moment in climate governance: carbon markets are expanding rapidly, but their credibility — and the flow of finance they can generate — depends on governments moving from aspirational frameworks to enforceable law.