Australia is moving closer to adopting a criminal offence for businesses that fail to prevent modern slavery in their operations and supply chains, a shift that would align the country with emerging international standards. However, experts caution that legal reforms alone will not be enough without a corresponding overhaul of policing strategies.
According to the Lowy Institute's The Interpreter, the framework proposed in October by Australia's Anti-Slavery Commissioner, Chris Evans, advocates for a "carefully designed criminal offence" targeting the most serious instances of criminal conduct. This would form part of a broader response that also includes a mandatory due diligence obligation for companies. The proposal follows the United Kingdom's recent announcement that it will legislate to require large businesses not only to report human rights and labour exploitation risks but also to actively address them, bringing UK law closer to the OECD Guidelines for Responsible Business Conduct and the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. Evans has welcomed this international momentum.
The push for stronger legal measures comes amid growing evidence linking modern slavery to organised crime. A recent report by New South Wales Anti-Slavery Commissioner James Cockayne alleged connections between labour hire practices and criminal groups involved in illicit tobacco trading and human trafficking for sexual exploitation. Cockayne identified "the lack of effective, proactive policing" as a central weakness in Australia's current response, according to The Interpreter. The findings follow the NSW government's response to 31 recommendations from the Modern Slavery Committee on risks faced by temporary migrant workers in regional NSW, a response that The Interpreter notes made no reference to organised crime.
The article argues that reactive policing, which responds to isolated incidents, cannot uncover the broader criminal networks that often underpin modern slavery. Criminals do not limit themselves to a single crime type, and the failure to connect the dots allows exploitation to persist. The scale of the problem is illustrated by the hundreds of thousands of people trafficked into the global cyber-scam industry in Southeast Asia and beyond, where victims are forced, sometimes tortured, to commit fraud. Some companies implicated in these schemes may be unaware of the exploitation in their supply chains, but others, the article states, were established specifically to provide financial and logistical support to a trillion-dollar scam economy alongside legitimate activities.
The United Nations reports that trafficking in persons is no longer confined to traditional forms; digital technologies have transformed methods of recruitment, control, and exploitation. Supply chains now extend beyond raw materials and manufacturers to include social media platforms, cryptocurrency companies, advertising technology firms, and artificial intelligence developers, many of which operate with opaque business models. Confronting human rights abuses and organised crime along these chains requires coordinated action across multiple legal regimes in different countries, not just a single regulatory framework.
The article, written by Dr. Marika McAdam, an independent adviser on criminal justice and human rights, emphasises that the connection between modern slavery and organised crime is not new. The global understanding of trafficking in persons was originally developed within the framework of a treaty on transnational organised crime. McAdam argues that neither criminal law nor business supply chain regulation alone can provide a complete response to modern slavery, a phenomenon that has proven conceptually and practically difficult to pin down. Governments must create an enabling environment that incentivises businesses to fulfil their human rights responsibilities, while also taking a proactive policing approach to companies that are not on a good-faith human rights journey but are pursuing a criminal agenda.
The article concludes by recalling a letter written in 1865 by Jourdon Anderson, a former slave, to his former enslaver. Anderson set conditions for returning to work, including payment for years of unpaid wages with interest, and reminded his former master that "surely there will be a day of reckoning for those who defraud the labourer of his hire." The modern-day reckoning, McAdam writes, must hold businesses accountable not only for human rights failures but also for criminal actions.