The Netherlands is struggling to push through domestic tax reforms, including a long-delayed new regime for taxing savings and investments, while the European Commission is pressing ahead with a sweeping proposal to simplify corporate taxation across the bloc. The contrast was the focus of a conference at Leiden University, where scholars, politicians, tax specialists and policymakers gathered to discuss the implications of the so-called Omnibus Package for the Dutch tax system.
The Netherlands' minority coalition government has found it difficult to secure parliamentary backing for its annual Tax Plan, according to Leiden University. The new Box 3 regime, which governs the taxation of savings and investments, has been postponed once again. Without a stable majority, the government must negotiate support from other parties for each proposal, making major reforms hard to advance.
Meanwhile, the European Commission has tabled the Omnibus Package, a single legislative initiative that aims to amend multiple European tax rules for businesses at once. The proposal is driven by concerns about Europe's competitiveness, as highlighted in a widely discussed report by former European Central Bank President Mario Draghi. Draghi warned that Europe is falling behind the United States and China, partly because the single market remains fragmented by national barriers. Taxation is a clear example: a Dutch company operating in Germany and France must navigate three different sets of rules.
Noor Sanders, Director-General for Fiscal Affairs at the Dutch Ministry of Finance, told the conference that the current system creates more than just paperwork. 'That's not just an administrative burden. It also affects liquidity, certainty and processing times,' she said, referring to the example of dividend tax, where one country grants an exemption immediately while another requires upfront payment with a refund months later.
For the Netherlands, the Omnibus Package raises three potentially difficult issues, according to the conference discussions. First, European rules often set only a minimum standard, allowing individual countries to adopt stricter measures. The Netherlands deliberately took a tougher approach on how much interest companies can deduct from their profits, aiming to discourage excessive debt financing. If Europe harmonises these rules, the national room for manoeuvre could shrink.
Second, simpler rules could mean lower tax revenues. Any shortfall would have to be made up elsewhere, and it is not clear how the measures would benefit the economy. The Dutch House of Representatives has asked the Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis (CPB) to assess the impact. 'If it were that straightforward, it would already have been done,' Sanders added. 'We need to find out whether the package of measures, taken as a whole, will strengthen our competitiveness and weigh that against the cost to the treasury.'
Third, decisions on the package will be made in Brussels by all member states collectively. While the Ministry of Finance provides the negotiating mandate, it does not itself have a seat at the table. 'We will not take any irreversible decisions without informing Parliament in good time,' Sanders said.
The conference featured panels with experts, policymakers and business representatives. Jan van de Streek discussed the taxation of profits that subsidiaries pass on to parent companies. While he broadly supports a single market without taxes on dividend payments, he warned that this could create budget shortfalls for individual countries. 'If new taxes are introduced to make up for that, we may simply be jumping out of the frying pan into the fire,' Van de Streek said.
Loes van Hulten (Erasmus University/Deloitte) noted that simplifying the system also raises questions about how to continue tackling tax avoidance, particularly when countries implement the rules in different ways. A second panel, including Jan Vleggeert, focused on interest deductibility, the area where the Netherlands opted for stricter rules.
The conference concluded with a debate between MPs Luc Stultiens (PRO), Henk-Jan Oosterhuis (D66) and Michiel Hoogeveen (JA21), along with Dirk-Jan Sinke, representing both VNO-NCW and MKB-Nederland; Bas Jorissen, a tax consultant and Leiden graduate; and Indra Römgens from the FNV. Jorissen drew a parallel between the plan to eliminate taxes on EU dividend movements and the removal of customs tariffs during the 1960s, and suggested a common tax when dividends leave Europe.
For university students, particularly those studying law, economics, or European affairs, the Omnibus Package represents a real-world case of how EU policy-making directly affects national fiscal sovereignty and business operations. The outcome of these negotiations could shape career opportunities in tax law, corporate finance, and EU institutions, as well as influence the cost of doing business for future employers.
The position the Dutch government takes in Brussels will signal where future tax decisions will be made: not only in The Hague, but increasingly at the European level.