Closing a coal-fired power plant is often seen as a clear win for the climate, but for the communities that depend on those plants for jobs, school funding and civic life, the aftermath can be devastating. Researchers at Arizona State University's Just Energy Transition Center are arguing that state policy has not kept up with the human cost of these closures, and they have put forward a set of recommendations to change that.

According to a report from ASU News, the Navajo Generating Station in Page, Arizona, shut down in 2019, leading to an estimated loss of 1,000 jobs and $40 million in annual revenue for the Navajo Nation. The closure was abrupt, leaving little time for the community to prepare. Across the state, similar transitions are playing out at other coal plants, often with no guaranteed financial protections for the affected areas.

The ASU team, led by center director Amanda Ormond, spent 18 months conducting community-centered research, funded by a grant from the Resilient Energy Economies Initiative. They convened a statewide advisory committee that included a former utility executive, a utility regulator, a community advocate, a state senator, a school superintendent and other experts. Together, they produced a policy brief with nine recommendations aimed at state legislators and decision-makers.

Ormond told ASU News that the human dimension of plant closures is often overlooked. Coal plants are typically the largest taxpayer in their county and the largest taxpayer for the school system, she said. When a plant closes, the loss of tax revenue can cripple public services. The social impact is also significant: workers earning $100,000 or more may have to move for new jobs, splitting up families, and the utility's philanthropic support for local events like baseball teams or Fourth of July parades often disappears.

One key challenge the researchers identified is that Arizona's tax system does not break out revenue by individual assets, making it difficult for counties to know exactly how much money they are losing from a specific plant. The team recommends conducting specific studies to quantify the fiscal and job impacts of each closure.

Ormond noted that other states have established processes for supporting coal communities, such as rate cases or settlement agreements with utilities that provide funding, job training or help identifying new businesses. Arizona has no such framework. The first recommendation in the brief is to designate a state agency responsible for helping transitioning communities, something Ormond said the governor could do without legislation.

The brief also calls for forming committees for each plant that is transitioning and for funding mechanisms to support communities. Ormond acknowledged that the funding recommendations would require approval from the Arizona Corporation Commission if they involve regulated utilities like Arizona Public Service (APS) giving money to a community like Cholla.

Ormond also discussed the concept of Community Benefit Agreements, which are negotiated agreements that require developers to pay benefits to a community during and after a project's lifecycle. She argued that such agreements should apply to all types of development, not just renewable energy projects, and noted that new pipelines in Apache and Navajo counties should also contribute.

When coal plants are repowered as gas plants, the job losses remain severe. Ormond said she has heard that two-thirds of the jobs from a coal plant are lost when it repowers to gas, and the remaining jobs often require different skills and can be managed remotely, meaning local workers may not benefit.

The ASU team's work is grounded in direct community engagement. Ormond described holding visioning sessions with residents to help them think about what they want to maintain and grow, and then providing studies and capacity to explore options like a gas plant or a battery recycling facility. She emphasized that ASU does not presume to know what is best for these communities, but instead listens and co-creates solutions.

The policy brief is part of a broader effort to make the green energy transition more inclusive. Ormond said the goal is to ensure that rural and tribal communities are not left behind when fossil fuel plants close, and that they have a say in what comes next.