Researchers from Wageningen University & Research (WUR) are calling on the European Union to place agriculture at the centre of its long-term transition to a bioeconomy, warning that current policy lacks a clear plan for where the necessary biomass will come from.

Speaking at the annual Mansholt Lecture in Brussels on 17 November, three WUR scientists presented a report arguing that without a deliberate shift in agricultural production, the EU's vision of replacing fossil fuels with renewable biological materials will fail.

"The problem is that the current EU strategy does not specify where the biomass needed for the bioeconomy will come from. Without biomass, there is no bioeconomy. It is as simple as that," said Allard Jellema, an agriculture and food policy researcher at WUR, according to the university's news service.

The European Union has been working since 2025 toward a transition in which biomass — crops, crop residues, wood and algae — replaces fossil fuels as the main industrial feedstock. Such materials can be used to produce plastics, biofuels and other products. Proponents argue that a fully developed bioeconomy would reduce greenhouse gas emissions and decrease Europe's reliance on imported fossil fuels.

But the WUR researchers contend that the EU has not addressed the fundamental question of supply. At present, European agriculture imports biomass, mainly for animal feed. Without policy changes, the same pattern could repeat for bioeconomy feedstocks, undermining the environmental and strategic benefits of the transition, the report argues.

Jellema said that industrial and agricultural policies need to be linked to ensure the production of the right types of biomass. "We need to shift the focus of the CAP away from livestock farming and use it much more strategically to stimulate biomass production for purposes other than animal feed," he said, referring to the Common Agricultural Policy, through which the EU distributes more than €50 billion annually to farmers.

Currently, CAP payments are largely determined by farm size, which the researchers say disproportionately benefits livestock farmers. They argue that the policy should instead reward farmers for growing crops needed for the bioeconomy, such as those used to produce sustainable materials or biofuels.

However, the report stresses that stimulating agricultural production alone is not enough. "You can encourage farmers to produce biomass, but without a market, it will not work. We need to ensure that policies across all sectors are aligned, from agriculture through to consumption," Jellema said.

The Mansholt Lecture advocates an integrated approach involving industry and consumers. Jellema pointed to the need to encourage people to wear clothes for longer and move away from fast fashion, and said EU policies promoting reuse and repair can help. "Only by using raw materials more efficiently can biomass meet all our needs," he said.

Alongside Jellema, value chain specialist Harriëtte Bos and Professor of Plant Breeding Agnieszka Golicz spoke at the event. Both contributed to the accompanying report.

The researchers also highlighted economic opportunities. "At present, much of the chemical industry is leaving Europe. This sector could benefit enormously from a bioeconomy," Jellema said. "Because the bioeconomy is still in its infancy, we have a real opportunity to shape its future direction. The EU is in a privileged position to embark on a new path."

The Mansholt Lecture is named after Sicco Mansholt, a former Dutch Minister of Agriculture and European Commissioner. It is held annually in Brussels, where WUR scientists share their perspectives on a current policy issue.

For university students, the debate over the bioeconomy has direct implications. Future careers in agriculture, environmental science, chemical engineering, and policy will be shaped by how the EU chooses to restructure its economy. Students studying in Europe may also see changes in what is taught and researched, as universities respond to shifting policy priorities. Those considering careers in farming, food systems, or sustainability will find that the skills most in demand could change significantly if the EU follows the path the WUR researchers have outlined.