A new study published in Frontiers in Public Health argues that the biggest challenges refugees face during settlement are not primarily about individual trauma, but about structural barriers in housing, healthcare, and safety. The research, conducted by a team from ISPA—Instituto Universitário in Lisbon, Portugal, draws on in-depth interviews with 19 refugees living in the Lisbon area and applies the capability approach as an analytical framework.
According to the study, the capability approach offers a counter-framework to what the authors describe as a dominant "trauma and vulnerability-centered paradigm" in migration research. Rather than focusing mainly on psychiatric symptoms like PTSD, depression, or anxiety, the approach examines the real opportunities—or "capabilities"—that individuals have to pursue lives they value. These capabilities are shaped not only by personal abilities but also by social, economic, and political arrangements.
The researchers identified six interrelated capability-oriented dimensions from the interviews: life circumstances and emotions, access to healthcare services, housing security, bodily integrity, and control over one’s environment. Among these, housing, healthcare, and safety surfaced as the areas where the greatest gaps exist and where investment and accountability are most urgent, the study reported.
The study is situated within a growing body of research on post-migration living difficulties (PMLD), which over the past two decades has highlighted the profound impact of everyday post-migratory stressors on refugees’ well-being. The authors note that empirical studies indicate post-migratory stressors—such as discrimination, limited economic opportunities, restricted access to resources, and social isolation—are often stronger predictors of psychological distress among refugees than traumatic experiences occurring before or during migration.
For university students, the findings carry implications for how refugee and migrant communities are understood and supported on campus. The study suggests that a narrow focus on trauma and mental health may obscure the structural conditions—like housing insecurity or lack of access to healthcare—that students from refugee backgrounds may face. The authors call for a "social justice-oriented model toward fundamental human rights" and for a "contextual and structural turn in mental health."
The research was conducted in Lisbon, Portugal, a country that has committed to receiving refugees within the framework of the European Agenda for Migration since 2015. According to the study, refugee reception and settlement in Portugal are regulated by the national Asylum Law, and applications for international protection reached 2,693 in 2023. The authors note that while the number of asylum seekers in Portugal remains relatively low compared to other European countries, the structural challenges identified in the study may be relevant to other settlement contexts.
The study employed a hybrid deductive–inductive thematic coding approach, guided by the capability approach while allowing themes to emerge inductively from participants’ narratives. The authors emphasize that the capability approach, rather than being a fixed framework, should be adapted to specific cultural and contextual settings—something they argue has not yet been systematically undertaken in relation to refugees and other people on the move.
Ultimately, the study provides further evidence for a contextual and structural turn in mental health and for forms of knowledge production in migration studies, according to the authors. The research was published in the Public Mental Health section of Frontiers in Public Health on 18 November 2026.