A new doctoral dissertation from Leiden University is shedding light on a long-overlooked aspect of the Indonesian War of Independence: the sexual lives of Dutch troops. Historian Jonathan Verwey has reconstructed the sexual culture of the Dutch armed forces between 1945 and 1949, finding that despite strict official policies, sexual activity was widespread, sexually transmitted infections were common, and sexual misconduct went largely unpunished.
Verwey, who will defend his dissertation on 17 November, drew on diaries, letters, military policy documents, medical reports, and other archival materials to piece together what service members and military leaders thought about sex and relationships, and how they acted on those views. His book, also titled Tussen verlangen en geweld: De seksuele geschiedenis van de Nederlandse krijgsmacht in Indonesië 1945-1949 (Between Desire and Violence: The Sexual History of the Dutch Armed Forces in Indonesia, 1945-1949), is being published simultaneously by Boom Publishers.
According to Leiden University's announcement of the research, more than 130,000 volunteers and conscripts were deployed to Indonesia at a time when the Netherlands was in the midst of a campaign to promote public morality. After World War II, politicians, social groups, and Christian organisations had raised alarms about what they termed "moral decline" — divorce rates were rising, the number of children born outside marriage was increasing, and STIs were becoming more common.
Under this social pressure, the armed forces adopted a conservative stance on sexuality. Condoms were not distributed, and visits to brothels were not facilitated — a contrast with the practices of armies from the United States, the United Kingdom, and France at the time. Relationships with Indonesian or Indo-European women were discouraged due to racist prejudice. Medical examinations were even used to identify homosexual men, driven by fears that homosexuality could be "contagious."
In theory, Dutch military personnel — including the few thousand women serving in uniform, most of them around 20 years old — were expected to remain sexually abstinent throughout their deployment. "In reality, that was not what happened," Verwey told Leiden University. About half of the deployed service personnel were sexually active, and hundreds contracted an STI each week.
Verwey argues that the army leadership was more concerned about public perception than strict compliance with the rules. "They wanted to prevent stories appearing in the press about service personnel contracting sexually transmitted diseases on a large scale, entering into relationships with people in Indonesia or engaging in misconduct," he said.
The research also documents sexual misconduct, though Verwey notes that little was ever officially recorded about such incidents, making it difficult to determine how widespread they were. He found hundreds of references to sexual harassment, sexual abuse of power, and sexual violence. He found no evidence that sexual violence was used as an official military strategy, and most service personnel were never involved in it. However, many hundreds of service members were guilty of misconduct against civilian staff and civilians.
"Individual perpetrators often acted outside combat situations, while groups of perpetrators were more likely to commit abuses during military operations, interrogations or combat," Verwey said. "The armed forces rarely took action, as long as it didn’t attract attention."
According to Verwey, the military's sexual policies had negative effects across the board. Not distributing condoms had far-reaching consequences for sexual health. When it came to sexual violence, authorities repeatedly looked the other way. Those who were prosecuted generally received only light sentences, and victims were treated with suspicion, with their morality called into question.
The length of deployments also took a heavy toll. Although military doctors and chaplains advised the army leadership not to separate personnel from their families for more than a year and a half, demobilisation was postponed several times. As a result, many marriages and relationships came under strain and ultimately broke down.
For a long time, this history received little attention in either Indonesia or the Netherlands, and it still receives little public attention or political accountability. Verwey said he wanted to show that sexual policies and sexual experiences played a far bigger role within the armed forces than is generally assumed.
"It affected the lives of all 220,000 serving military personnel, as well as those of millions of men and women outside the military," he said. "They carried these sexual experiences with them for the rest of their lives, both the positive ones and the negative."