New Zealand’s constitutional framework offers weaker protections for Indigenous rights than comparable countries, leaving Māori rights subject to the shifting priorities of coalition politics, according to Claire Charters, a professor at Auckland Law School specialising in Indigenous peoples’ rights under international and constitutional law.
Writing for the University of Auckland, Charters argues that the country’s current system allows Parliament — led by the executive — to override rights, meaning that political negotiation, not law, determines whether Indigenous rights are upheld. “We are an outlier in this globally,” she writes. “In comparable countries indigenous rights aren’t up for negotiation in a coalition deal or subject to the whim of the government of the day.”
Charters points to the aftermath of the 2023 general election as a clear example. The minority ACT Party, led by David Seymour, made the introduction of the Treaty Principles Bill a condition of the coalition agreement with National and New Zealand First. She describes the bill as “a threat to Māori rights, which it actively sought to undermine, undoing decades of incremental work to slowly build a country based on respect for our founding constitutional document, te Tiriti o Waitangi, the Treaty of Waitangi.” The bill, she says, created more social division than any issue since the Foreshore and Seabed Act of 2004.
International bodies have also raised concerns. In July 2026, the Human Rights Commission released an analysis finding that the then-government’s proposals to amend references to the Treaty of Waitangi in 19 pieces of legislation were inconsistent with domestic and international human rights standards, according to Charters. The UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD) issued a series of recommendations for New Zealand, expressing concern about reduced Māori political participation following changes to Māori wards, the 2025 Electoral Act amendments that abolished same-day voting registration and barred prisoners from voting, and the initiatives behind the Treaty Principles Bill. Minister for Māori-Crown Relations Tama Potaka noted that the inquiry offered “useful insights on issues of considerable importance to New Zealand,” but the government took no direct action to address the recommendations, Charters reports.
Charters contrasts New Zealand’s approach with stronger protections elsewhere. In Canada, First Nations, Métis and Inuit aboriginal and treaty rights have been protected as higher law since 1982, meaning Canadian law must respect those rights or risk being overturned. The Sámi people in northern Europe have independent parliaments in Norway, Sweden and Finland, with a Saami Council operating across four countries, ensuring a say in law-making. In Australia, a treaty signed in November 2025 between Victoria First Nations and the Victoria state government recognises Aboriginal peoples’ self-determination, with a First Peoples’ Assembly acting as the official voice.
Looking ahead, Charters warns that if National, NZ First and ACT form the next government, there is a risk of the Waitangi Tribunal being effectively disestablished, ongoing weakening of Treaty clauses in legislation, continued undermining of tikanga Māori, and discussion about the abolition of the Māori seats. With a Labour-led coalition, she expects the approach would be “too incremental and conservative to effect the urgently needed changes” she outlines in her new book, Sovereignty: The Case for Constitutional Transformation.
“What this election makes abundantly clear is that constitutional questions need a more stable home than in the horse-traded and incoherent policies of the government of the day,” Charters writes. She argues that changes are needed not only for Indigenous rights but also for equality, the rule of law, democracy, and to protect against divisive politics.
The article reflects the opinion of the author and not necessarily the views of the University of Auckland. It was first published by Stuff.