A new study published in Frontiers in Education suggests that China's reformed National College Entrance Examination (NCEE), known as the gaokao, is helping the country's elite universities attract stronger applicants — a key goal of the parallel "Double First-Class" (DFC) initiative.
The research, led by Yuchen Zhang and colleagues at Hangzhou Dianzi University, analysed admissions data from 105 universities and 14,170 majors in Shandong Province between 2018 and 2022. Shandong was among the second wave of provinces to implement the new NCEE, doing so fully in 2020, making its data a useful test case for the reform's effects.
Using a statistical technique called interrupted time-series analysis, the researchers measured changes in the "quality of student application" (QSA) — a metric that captures how competitive admitted students are — before and after the reform. They found that QSA improved significantly at both world-class universities (a category that includes institutions like Peking and Tsinghua) and first-class discipline universities (a broader group of 105 specialised institutions).
The reform's impact was not uniform across all regions. According to the study, DFC universities located in first-tier cities (such as Beijing and Shanghai), new first-tier cities (like Chengdu and Hangzhou), and second-tier cities all saw improvements in applicant quality, with the largest estimated gains at institutions in second-tier cities.
Different academic majors also experienced varying effects, the researchers reported. While the paper does not single out specific disciplines, the authors note that the numerical patterns in their estimates suggest a broader trend: high-scoring students appear to weigh both institutional prestige and urban location heavily when making their choices.
What changed in the gaokao?
The new NCEE, rolled out nationally in phases since 2014, introduced two major changes. First, it scrapped the rigid division between liberal arts and science tracks. Students now take three compulsory subjects (Chinese, maths, and a foreign language) and choose three electives from a pool of six or seven, including physics, chemistry, biology, history, and politics. Second, the admissions model shifted from "college first, then major" to "major plus college" — meaning students now apply directly to a specific programme at a specific university, rather than first being admitted to a university and then assigned a major. The old model carried a risk of involuntary major assignment; the new one eliminates that risk entirely, according to the study.
These changes were designed to give students more flexibility and to reduce mismatches between student interests and their assigned programmes. The researchers argue that this more refined "screening mechanism" helps top universities attract students who are not only high-scoring but also genuinely interested in their chosen field.
Why this matters for students
For Chinese university applicants, the findings suggest that the reformed gaokao may be making it easier for high-performing students to secure places at their preferred elite institutions and programmes. The study's authors frame this as a positive development for the DFC initiative, which aims to build world-class universities and disciplines by 2050. Attracting top students is widely seen as critical to that goal.
However, the study also points to potential disparities. The fact that QSA gains varied by city tier and by major implies that some universities and programmes may benefit more than others from the reform — a dynamic that could reshape the competitive landscape among China's elite institutions over time.
The researchers note that their findings are based on data from a single province, Shandong, and may not generalise to all of China. They call for further research using data from other provinces and longer time horizons to confirm the patterns they observed.
Still, the study provides some of the first empirical evidence that China's twin higher-education policy reforms — the new NCEE and the DFC initiative — may be working in tandem to concentrate top talent at the country's leading universities, a development with implications for students, university administrators, and policymakers alike.