A study published in Frontiers in Public Health has found that two specific financial behaviours — holding non-saving financial products and carrying non-housing debt — are associated with poorer self-rated health among adults in China. The research, which analysed data from the China Family Panel Studies (CFPS) covering the years 2018, 2020 and 2022, found no similar association for investment returns.
The study, led by researchers at Wuhan Fourth Hospital and The Central Hospital of Wuhan, examined three dimensions of financial behaviour: market participation (holding stocks, funds, bonds or similar products beyond bank deposits), borrowing (carrying any non-housing debt), and investment returns (self-reported annual profit or loss). The authors aimed to test whether these behaviours are directionally consistent in their association with self-rated health, a widely used summary measure that integrates physical, functional and psychological information.
According to the study, the odds of reporting better self-rated health were about 18% lower among those who held non-saving financial products (odds ratio 0.822, 95% confidence interval 0.774 to 0.872) and about 21% lower among those carrying non-housing debt (odds ratio 0.788, 95% confidence interval 0.753 to 0.825), compared with those who did not engage in these behaviours. The findings were based on 56,606 person-wave observations from the nationally representative survey.
Investment returns showed no statistically significant association with self-rated health (odds ratio 0.983, 95% confidence interval 0.926 to 1.044), the study reported.
The researchers also found that baseline market participation and debt status predicted worse health two years later, while baseline health predicted later debt status, suggesting a potential bidirectional relationship. However, within-person analyses — which track changes in the same individuals over time — yielded null results, meaning that when individuals changed their financial behaviour, there was no corresponding change in their self-rated health within the study period.
The study further examined whether the amount of debt mattered, beyond simply being in debt. The authors reported that among debtors, the amount owed showed no gradient or predictive value for self-rated health. "Being in debt mattered, the amount owed did not," the study concluded.
In an effort to understand the pathways linking financial behaviour to health, the researchers explored potential mediators including depressive symptoms, psychological distress, sleep quality, life satisfaction and future confidence. They found that the association between debt and poorer health was accompanied by associations with negative affect, while the association between market participation and poorer health was accompanied by associations with future confidence and life satisfaction. The authors cautioned that because exposure and mediator were measured in the same wave, these should be interpreted as decompositions of association rather than established mediation.
The study acknowledged important limitations. Both associations were found to be sensitive to unmeasured confounding, with E-values of 1.72 and 1.85, indicating that an unmeasured confounder would need to be moderately strong to fully explain away the observed associations. The authors therefore described their findings as "associations of limited robustness rather than as established effects."
Additionally, respondents lost to follow-up were younger and more urban, which may introduce selection bias. The study relied on self-reported financial data, which may be subject to recall error or social desirability bias. The authors also noted that non-housing debt in China is largely unsecured consumer and informal borrowing, and that these findings may not generalise to contexts where debt structures differ.
For university students, the findings offer a reminder that financial behaviours — particularly taking on non-housing debt and holding volatile financial products — may carry implications beyond immediate financial outcomes. While the study does not establish causation, it suggests that the psychological burden of debt and market participation could be relevant to overall wellbeing. Students managing loans, credit cards or investments may wish to consider not only the financial but also the potential health-related trade-offs.
The study was published in the Health Economics section of Frontiers in Public Health on 20 November 2026.