More than half of Americans have stopped talking to certain people about political news because of something they said, according to Pew Research Center. For many, avoiding the discomfort of conflict has become easier than trying to understand a different point of view. But a group of experts gathered on a recent episode of the Harvard Gazette podcast "Harvard Thinking" argue that learning to disagree effectively is a skill worth practicing — one that benefits not just society, but everyday life.
Julia Minson, a professor of public policy at the Harvard Kennedy School and author of "How to Disagree Better," compared the skill of disagreement to exercise. "We all know it's good for us, but none of us wants to do it, and you want to do it less when you have less practice," she said on the podcast. Minson noted that social media has made it easier to surround oneself with like-minded people, allowing the "muscle" of disagreement to atrophy over time. "I used to have to talk to people who disagreed with me, in part because I just didn't know what people believed until I talked to them," she said. "But now, because of social media, I can find hundreds of thousands of people who agree with me and entirely avoid the people who disagree with me."
The episode, hosted by Harvard Gazette writer Samantha Laine Perfas, also featured Sheila Heen, deputy director of the Harvard Negotiation Project and co-author of "Difficult Conversations: How to Discuss What Matters Most," and Neil Gross, a professor of sociology at Colby College and author of "What Happened to College: How Politics Broke Higher Education and What We Can Do to Fix It."
Heen pointed out that everyone arrives at college or the workplace with their own coping strategies for conflict, shaped by family and community experiences. "Whether or not we have skills is another question," she said. "Everybody is defaulting to whatever they have learned works for them." She added that the stakes of disagreement vary depending on power dynamics and personal history, making it harder for some people to speak up than others.
Gross, whose research focuses on higher education, said that colleges have long been seen as places where students should learn to engage with disagreement as part of democratic citizenship. But his interviews with about 100 college students across the country revealed that many are afraid to voice controversial political views — not because of professors, but because of peers. "They told me that they were worried about people just not wanting to be friends with them anymore," Gross said. He noted that in a post-COVID, social media-driven world, friendships are especially important to students, and the perceived risk of losing a friend over a disagreement often silences them.
Minson acknowledged that hierarchy plays a significant role in who feels safe disagreeing. "Even if you come to college and you feel like you hold a minority position relative to what most other freshmen in your dorms believe, the costs are higher to disagree if you are the less powerful person in the interaction," she said.
The podcast episode, available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube, explores practical strategies for rebuilding the skill of disagreement. Minson emphasized the importance of being precise about what one knows and doesn't know. "What I do think is necessary, though, is being much more precise with what we know and what we don't know and what we think we know and what we aren't sure about and the contradictions in our own heads, because I think that makes you come across as a more human person," she said. "The other person then is much more likely to appreciate and then reciprocate with the same level of nuance and uncertainty."
For university students, the message is directly relevant: learning to navigate disagreement is not just about politics, but about the daily business of living with others — in dorms, study groups, and future workplaces. As Heen put it, "Disagreement and conflict are part of being human and in relationships with other people, including relationships with ourselves."