The United States is at a "pivotal moment" in its foreign policy, with fundamental doubts about its willingness to maintain the global leadership role it has held for decades, former diplomat Richard Haass said during a Nov. 12 discussion at Dartmouth College.

Haass, president emeritus of the Council on Foreign Relations and a former director of policy planning at the State Department under President George W. Bush, spoke at an event sponsored by the Rockefeller Center for Public Policy, the John Sloan Dickey Center for International Understanding, and Dartmouth Dialogues. Professor of Government Benjamin Valentino moderated the discussion, which drew about 110 attendees in Filene Auditorium and roughly 400 online viewers, according to Dartmouth.

"The biggest single change in the world is that the United States has fundamental doubts, not about its ability, but about its willingness to play the sort of outsized role that we have played for 80 years," Haass said, as reported by Dartmouth. "We're at a pivotal moment where the United States has essentially pulled back from its role, and it's not quite clear what's going to take our place. And that's why this is such a consequential moment in history."

Speaking a week after the 2026 midterm elections, in which Democrats gained House and Senate seats, Haass — who identified himself as a Republican — said the country faces "a very interesting experiment with divided government." However, he downplayed the potential for that shift to alter America's global posture. "I don't think the midterm elections will make a whole lot of difference when it comes to America's role in the world," Haass said. "You may welcome that; and you may be unhappy with what I've just said."

Haass argued that Congress is a "distinctly minority partner" to presidential power on national security matters, a dynamic that predates the current administration. "If you think about the hundreds of times presidents of the United States have ordered the use of military force from small to large, virtually 99% of them were done without constitutional declarations of war," he said.

Where Congress could make a meaningful difference, Haass suggested, is by passing legislation to provide Ukraine with economic and military aid in its nearly five-year war with Russia. If President Donald Trump vetoed such a bill, Haass noted that Congress now has the votes to override the veto. Assistance to Ukraine would be "great for security and stability in Europe" and would also benefit Trump's own aspirations as a peacemaker, Haass said. Without U.S. support, Russian President Vladimir Putin — whose primary interest is retaining power — has no incentive to negotiate, he added.

Haass said the second Trump administration's abrupt shifts in policy and tone have rattled allies. "I think the conversation every government around the world is having, and I know this because I've had the conversation with them, is to what extent they can continue to rely on the United States; to what extent do they become more self sufficient; to what extent they define new partners; and to what extent they accommodate or come to some kind of terms with dangerous countries in their neighborhood," he said. Countries that once assumed U.S. policy stability are now diversifying their foreign policy portfolios, he added.

Haass pointed to a paradox in the administration's foreign policy: the decision to go into Iran. "And that is a decision that is totally, totally, totally at odds with his own foreign policy," Haass said. "If you read the national security strategy that was published a year ago, if you listened to Donald Trump over the years, this was not the foreign policy he thought he was introducing by going into Iran. So the only way to make sense of it is that his assumptions about how it would play out were fundamentally different." He added, "History has a wicked sense of irony."

On the war in Gaza, Valentino noted that Haass is one of the few foreign policy experts still advocating for a two-state solution for Israel and Palestinians. While Haass acknowledged that a Palestinian state is virtually impossible at present, he said the priority should be to "reduce the scale and harshness of the Israeli occupation of Gaza. The Palestinians are packed at a level of density that is just simply not right. We've got to stop land confiscation in the West Bank and settler violence. That is simply wrong."

Regarding China and Taiwan, Haass expressed skepticism that China would invade Taiwan by force. "The mainland is so dependent on economic relations with the rest of the world, what it sells and what it buys, that to go to war against Taiwan, risks that," he said. He also noted that Chinese President Xi Jinping may be weighing the fact that Russia's invasion of Ukraine and the U.S. war with Iran have not gone according to plan.

Haass highlighted what he called an under-reported development: the emergence of Japan as a major foreign policy actor. "And people forget that Japan is still the world's third-largest economy. It has one of the world's most capable militaries," he said. Japan views an independent Taiwan as part of its defensive strategy. If the U.S. could "strengthen the fabric of the nature of our relationship with Taiwan," tensions between China and Taiwan might ease, Haass said.

On military strength, Haass argued that the U.S. should focus on modernizing its armed forces. "We have essentially missed a generation of military modernization. We spend more than anybody else, but we don't have enough to show for it. So we've got to deal with that. But we know we don't have the luxury of a retreat, but we also don't have the luxury of not reforming," he said.

Gavin Cameron '30, a student who attended the talk and is interested in history and neuroscience, said he was particularly struck by Haass's take on China. "If the Trump administration is pursuing a realpolitik with China, that leaves not only Taiwan vulnerable, but also our ability to project power in Asia, vulnerable. I think that's not a good thing," Cameron said, according to Dartmouth.