As populations age and formal care systems remain fragmented, families are increasingly expected to fill the gaps — coordinating services, providing daily support, and adapting to repeated crises. A new Perspective article published in Frontiers in Public Health argues that this unpaid, often gendered work should be understood as "hidden public health infrastructure," and that treating family resilience as an unlimited private resource is both inaccurate and harmful to public health planning.
The article, authored by researchers from Nanjing University, Peking University, and Xiangtan University, draws on decades of scholarship — including sociologist Kari Wærness's concept of an "invisible welfare state" — to reframe family caregiving not as a personal or family attribute, but as a set of practical, ongoing activities that sustain older adults in their homes. The authors argue that resilience frameworks in caregiving research too often measure resilience as a trait a family either has or lacks, obscuring the actual work of organising care and the structural inequalities that shape who bears its costs.
"Family resilience is, in our view, neither unlimited nor free of cost," the authors write. They propose the concept of "resilience entropy" to describe the gradual disorganisation of family care arrangements that must adapt again and again without sufficient external support.
Three mechanisms of caregiving practice
The article identifies three interrelated mechanisms through which families sustain care:
Resource bricolage is the active assembly of informal, public, and private resources — from kin and neighbours to services, benefits, and paid help. Because care needs change over time and seldom fit neatly into one service category, families must coordinate services that were designed separately.
Emotional negotiation concerns how responsibility, obligation, fatigue, and uncertainty about care are distributed within the family. Decisions about who will provide care, whether to pay for help, and how far an older person's wishes should prevail are rarely settled without guilt or conflict. The authors note this process is deeply gendered, as women are more likely to take on intensive caregiving and face stronger moral expectations to provide it.
Institutional translation describes how families make sense of fragmented rules, eligibility criteria, service procedures, and administrative requirements, and turn them into practical support for an older relative. This involves judging whether they qualify, preparing documents, talking with professionals, and keeping several agencies in step. Differences in education and institutional knowledge can affect how families carry out this work, reproducing inequalities in access to care.
The authors emphasise that these mechanisms can support one another when resources and services are accessible, but under sustained pressure and insufficient support, difficulties in one mechanism may place additional demands on the others.
What this means for students
For university students studying public health, social work, gerontology, or health policy, the article offers a conceptual framework that challenges conventional approaches to resilience. Rather than measuring resilience as an individual or family trait, the authors argue for examining the actual practices through which care is organised — and the structural conditions that make those practices possible or impossible.
The article also has practical implications for students who may become family caregivers themselves, or who will enter professions that interact with care systems. Understanding that caregiving is work — work that requires resources, emotional labour, and institutional navigation — can inform how students approach both their studies and their future careers.
Policy implications
The authors propose several public health responses: optional familialism (supporting families who choose to provide care without assuming they must), equitable access to support, and assessment of emerging difficulties before care arrangements become unstable. They argue that public health systems should "recognise, support, and redistribute caregiving capacity" and should not treat family adaptation as a renewable private resource.
The article draws on examples from across OECD countries, noting that even in Nordic countries with relatively generous care provision, family care has not disappeared. Swedish national data from 1992 to 2021 show a long-term decline in home care services and growing reliance on family care, particularly from partners. In Norway, relatives act as intermediaries between frail older adults and a complex service system, meaning institutional translation remains a family task even where provision is generous.
China, where the authors are based, illustrates the coexistence of expanding formal provision and constraints on family care. The article notes that older adults in China are themselves part of these practices — they negotiate their own care, and many continue giving through financial transfers and care for grandchildren.
A call to rethink resilience
The article joins a growing body of scholarship that questions the uncritical use of resilience as a concept in health services research. The authors cite Suslovic and Lett, who have proposed that resilience be regarded as an adverse event in health services research, because the concept shifts attention away from the conditions that repeatedly require disadvantaged groups to adapt.
By reframing family caregiving as hidden public health infrastructure, the article invites researchers, policymakers, and practitioners to see the work families do — and to ask what would happen if that infrastructure were to break down.