A pedagogical innovation that coordinates the timing of knowledge acquisition and joint problem-solving tasks across three interdependent courses can significantly improve students' adaptive problem solving (APS) skills, according to a study published in Frontiers in Education.
The research, led by T K Tamás Köpeczi-Bócz at the University of Tokaj in Hungary, compared APS development among 97 students over two academic years. Fifty-two students received integrated instruction across business mathematics, statistics, and information technology courses, while 45 students followed conventional separate-subject teaching. The study used a non-randomised quantitative pre–post comparison design.
Adaptive problem solving is the ability to recognise a problem, select relevant information, plan a solution, and modify the strategy when circumstances change. The OECD introduced APS as a separate assessment domain in the second cycle of the Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC). According to the OECD's 2023 survey, an average of 29% of adults across participating countries performed at or below APS proficiency Level 1. The OECD also found that proficiency one standard deviation higher was associated with 7% higher hourly earnings and a four-percentage-point higher probability of labour-force participation.
For university students, the implication is clear: the ability to flexibly apply knowledge alongside a degree can strengthen the professional usefulness and value of that qualification. The World Economic Forum's 2025 employer projections also identify creative thinking, resilience, flexibility, and adaptability among sought-after skills.
The study measured APS development across six pedagogical dimensions derived from workplace adaptation tasks and the OECD APS framework: problem identification and clarification (D1); appraisal of information and evidence (D2); generation of alternatives (D3); decision-making and justification (D4); monitoring and correction (D5); and reflective evaluation of the problem-solving process (D6). Teachers assessed students at the beginning and end of each semester using four ordered developmental levels.
According to the study, the mean APS development under the integrated configuration was 1.965 analytical code units, compared to 1.059 under separate-subject instruction — a difference of +0.905. All six dimensions improved for 45 of the 52 students in the integrated groups, compared with only 9 of the 45 students in the separate-subject groups. Higher final developmental levels were substantially more frequent under integrated instruction.
The innovation did not require additional courses or teaching hours. Instead, it involved deliberate coordination of prerequisite knowledge across the three subjects. Teachers planned collaboratively to sequence learning activities so that knowledge from one course could be applied in another during joint problem-solving tasks. The study reports that the additional pedagogical benefit was achieved while retaining existing course requirements and teaching arrangements.
After two academic years of comparative implementation, and taking student requests into account, the institution adopted the integrated configuration as standard teaching practice. The study notes that the process of experimentation, empirical evaluation, student feedback, and institutional adoption completed a full pedagogical innovation cycle.
For degree programmes, the findings identify a practical way to strengthen observable problem-solving development through coordination of existing courses, rather than adding new ones. The study's authors argue that the transferable design principle consists of identifying knowledge dependencies across subjects, sequencing learning accordingly, and designing complex tasks for joint application.
The study acknowledges limitations, including its non-randomised design and its focus on a single institutional context. The findings are drawn from one programme at one university, and the authors note that further research would be needed to test the generalisability of the approach across different disciplines and institutions.
Nevertheless, the study provides comparative evidence linking a specific curriculum coordination strategy to measurable APS development, and documents its successful adoption as standard practice.