Prime Minister Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget included a pledge to eliminate homelessness in Canada within ten years, describing the problem as something that "strikes at the heart of Canadian values of fairness, solidarity, and human dignity." But according to Nicole Fice, an assistant professor in the School of Health Studies at Western University, the announcement left a key question unanswered: what exactly are those values, and how does homelessness violate them?
Writing in The Conversation and republished by Western News, Fice draws on empirical and philosophical research to build an ethical case for why the federal commitment matters — and why Canadians should hold policy accountable to the principles it invokes.
Dignity eroded
Fice argues that homelessness undermines human dignity, which she defines as the inherent worth every person holds equally by virtue of being human. Dignity is the foundation of human rights, she writes, and those rights include an adequate standard of housing. When people are homeless, they experience a loss of dignity not only through the violation of that right, but through shame, ostracism and exclusion from meaningful participation in social life.
"Homelessness excludes people from meaningful participation in social life," Fice writes. "That leaves them on the margins of society, with little to no resources or options, reduced social status and a lack of freedom and authority over their lives since much of what they do, even just to survive, is criminalized."
Some government responses to homeless encampments, she notes, have also been found to violate rights guaranteed under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, further compounding the harm.
What a just society looks like
Fice turns to political philosophy to explain why homelessness is fundamentally unfair. She cites the work of American philosopher John Rawls, whose theory of "justice as fairness" holds that any social and economic inequalities in a just society should benefit the least advantaged members. While Rawls did not explicitly list housing as a good to be distributed fairly, Fice notes that scholars have argued it must be included.
"The fact that homelessness exists to the degree it does in a wealthy country like Canada does in fact suggest a lack of fairness in a broader distributive sense," she writes. "Some people are left without shelter altogether, some have subpar shelter while others have plenty."
She also draws on a relational view of justice, which holds that a just society is one where people stand as equals rather than in hierarchies. From that perspective, the state's failure to adequately respond to homelessness demonstrates a lack of equal concern for some of the most vulnerable members of society.
Health inequities and collective responsibility
Homelessness disproportionately affects certain populations, Fice writes, and leads to vicious cycles of poor health, higher risk of infectious disease and premature death. These are not merely individual misfortunes, she argues, but systemic injustices that demand a collective response.
"The concept of solidarity speaks to the need for society generally to address injustices as a collective," she writes. "Failing to do so results in the social and moral abandonment of people experiencing homelessness as they are left to suffer the injustices of homelessness alone."
Fice acknowledges that the causes of homelessness are complex and multi-faceted, worsened by a lack of affordable housing, higher unemployment and rising inflation. But she cites research showing that experts and advocates agree homelessness is not caused by individual choices, but by societal choices.
Translating values into action
Fice argues that while the ethical case for ending homelessness is compelling, the real work lies in translating justification into action. Canadians, she says, should monitor whether the promised federal funds produce outcomes that align with the values of dignity, fairness and solidarity.
"We need to ensure our policies not only reflect our ethical values, but also produce outcomes that actively support them," she writes. "We must consider whether the policies and programs implemented align with our ethical values, and whether their outcomes are effective in promoting them as well."
For university students, the analysis raises questions about how public policy can be held accountable to ethical principles — and what role citizens, including students, can play in ensuring that a wealthy country like Canada follows through on its moral commitments.